On Consistency of Cross-Approximate Entropy in Cardiovascular and Artificial Environments

<div>Unreliable estimated probabilities <svg height="14.0148pt" id="M342" style="vertical-align:-3.943501pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -10.0713 53.4516 14.0148" width="53.4516pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,1.781,-1.044)"><path d="M470 557C393 591 314 624 246 666H224C156 624 76 591 0 557L12 532C86 550 163 573 235 596C309 572 384 550 458 532L470 557Z" id="g119-17"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M570 304C570 398 525 448 414 448C385 448 343 445 312 434L329 511L321 518C297 504 262 482 244 460L233 411C195 397 159 381 128 358L135 332C160 347 189 360 224 373L111 -147C97 -210 84 -218 17 -231L13 -257L254 -247L259 -218L233 -216C183 -212 177 -202 189 -142L218 -1C238 -10 266 -12 283 -12C351 3 429 48 483 105C543 168 570 242 570 304ZM482 289C482 161 380 33 304 33C278 33 248 51 233 69L303 396C326 400 352 403 369 403C428 403 482 380 482 289Z" id="g113-113"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,7.71,-5.741)"><path d="M781 91L765 118C733 86 702 70 693 70C686 70 685 77 692 106L738 297C772 439 736 451 712 451S675 445 647 431C605 410 526 356 452 257H450L459 294C491 426 459 451 429 451C403 451 386 445 361 431C312 404 239 343 170 253H168L188 333C208 411 205 451 175 451C148 451 85 417 24 346L39 318C57 338 100 374 112 374C120 374 122 372 115 339C91 226 62 112 28 -6L37 -12C59 -4 87 3 114 6C125 68 142 127 154 168C184 227 316 383 372 383C397 383 396 366 381 289C362 192 338 92 312 -6L317 -12C339 -5 367 3 396 6L434 170C468 234 598 383 650 383C668 383 676 369 664 319L609 90C593 23 600 -12 629 -12C654 -12 722 23 781 91Z" id="g50-110"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,7.384,3.784)"><path d="M250 606C250 634 233 656 203 656C168 656 146 618 146 593C146 564 169 545 192 545C227 545 250 573 250 606ZM227 95L212 119C187 98 152 71 135 71C129 71 128 78 134 102L207 373C219 418 217 451 194 451C165 451 92 411 30 351L44 326C77 353 106 371 114 371C124 371 121 357 117 341L55 97C32 5 46 -12 70 -12C108 -12 191 51 227 95Z" id="g50-106"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,15.589,0)"><path d="M300 -147C201 -63 143 98 143 270S200 602 300 686L282 710C136 610 70 450 70 271V270C70 89 136 -72 282 -170L300 -147Z" id="g113-41"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,20.087,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,25.575,0)"><path d="M275 270C275 450 212 609 64 710L45 686C145 604 203 442 203 270S147 -63 45 -147L64 -170C213 -68 275 89 275 270Z" id="g113-42"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.431,0)"><path d="M290 -163V-135C183 -126 181 -122 181 -44V583C181 662 184 666 290 675V703H120V-163H290Z" id="g113-92"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,38.916,0)"><path d="M594 629L561 652L159 -9L190 -32L594 629ZM194 635C92 635 49 534 49 453C49 374 92 272 193 272C295 272 338 374 338 454S295 635 194 635ZM193 605C257 605 265 504 265 453C265 405 257 302 194 302C133 302 122 403 122 454S133 605 193 605ZM567 351C465 351 421 250 421 169C421 90 465 -12 566 -12S710 90 710 170S667 351 567 351ZM566 322C628 322 637 221 637 169C637 121 628 18 567 18S494 119 494 170C494 223 506 322 566 322Z" id="g121-35"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,48.744,0)"><path d="M226 -163V703H56V676C162 667 165 662 165 584V-43C165 -122 162 -126 56 -136V-163H226Z" id="g113-94"></path></g></svg> in real signals; (a) <svg height="12.5155pt" id="M343" style="vertical-align:-3.22717pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.28833 81.6151 12.5155" width="81.6151pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,9.12,0)"><path d="M448 1V51H364C248 51 153 129 140 230H448V280H140C153 381 248 459 364 459H448V509H365C208 509 80 395 80 255S208 1 365 1H448Z" id="g117-173"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,19.616,0)"><path d="M293 -169V-141C218 -131 209 -90 209 -44C209 19 222 85 222 152C222 207 198 255 139 269V273C199 286 222 334 222 388C222 454 209 523 209 588C209 632 218 671 293 681V709C234 709 148 695 148 577C147 513 155 438 155 372C155 337 152 291 64 285V256C152 250 155 204 155 169C156 105 148 31 148 -41C148 -157 234 -169 293 -169Z" id="g113-124"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,24.127,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,29.028,3.132)"><path d="M665 0V33C595 38 568 55 523 124C476 196 422 278 366 366C436 471 466 514 487 540C533 599 553 609 628 617V650H396V617C459 610 463 599 440 558C413 507 382 460 343 400C300 467 263 522 232 575C216 602 218 609 278 617V650H27V617C100 609 114 598 160 531C193 479 239 409 291 325C206 194 151 118 127 89C99 53 67 38 8 33V0H242V33C177 41 172 50 196 91C229 151 269 219 316 288C380 189 422 120 446 81C465 49 459 38 398 33V0H665Z" id="g58-86"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,34.933,3.132)"><path d="M969 650H746V617C823 609 825 598 814 540C798 470 743 278 700 144H698C638 319 581 476 525 641H491C440 478 384 317 329 145H327C283 286 245 418 205 553C192 601 192 609 267 617V650H20V617C80 609 98 602 122 522C177 343 233 172 285 -9H321C372 152 428 309 485 485H487C542 330 604 151 660 -9H696C779 269 841 460 862 521C891 599 900 609 969 617V650Z" id="g58-85"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,44.478,0)"><path d="M95 130C70 130 46 113 46 88C46 72 54 64 59 64C93 55 121 33 121 -3C121 -41 93 -68 44 -88L55 -117C117 -98 186 -56 186 22C186 91 131 130 95 130Z" id="g113-45"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,49.622,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,54.523,3.132)"><path d="M592 498C586 556 582 629 581 675H560C545 656 537 650 510 650H115C87 650 74 652 60 675H40C38 620 33 555 28 495H57C69 539 77 568 89 585C102 607 122 616 205 616H267V123C267 44 259 34 168 28V0H454V28C360 34 352 44 352 123V616H422C498 616 514 608 531 584C542 568 552 543 562 495L592 498Z" id="g190-85"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,60.137,3.132)"><path d="M729 650H468V622C546 615 554 610 554 527V365H213V527C213 610 221 616 297 622V650H38V622C120 616 128 611 128 527V123C128 39 120 34 40 28V0H303V28C221 34 213 40 213 123V322H554V123C554 39 546 34 460 28V0H728V28C647 34 639 39 639 123V527C639 610 647 615 729 622V650Z" id="g190-73"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,67.108,3.132)"><path d="M300 253H71L57 198H286L300 253Z" id="g190-46"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,70.348,3.132)"><path d="M655 0V28C585 35 563 50 517 120C469 193 414 280 360 366C427 469 460 516 481 545C526 604 545 614 619 622V650H391V622C457 614 462 604 438 560C411 511 381 463 339 398C295 466 258 523 225 580C210 606 211 615 272 622V650H26V622C98 614 111 603 154 538C189 482 235 408 288 324C200 188 149 116 124 85C95 47 64 34 7 28V0H236V28C169 36 164 46 188 89C220 148 261 217 310 291C372 193 417 118 442 77C461 44 454 35 392 28V0H655Z" id="g190-89"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,76.879,0)"><path d="M283 255V284C195 290 192 337 192 375C192 436 200 508 200 580C200 696 116 709 54 709V681C127 671 139 634 139 588C138 524 125 452 125 387C125 333 149 286 209 272V268C148 253 125 206 125 151C126 87 139 16 139 -47C139 -92 127 -131 54 -141V-169C115 -169 200 -152 200 -41C200 32 192 104 192 164C192 202 195 249 283 255Z" id="g113-126"></path></g></svg> and weak criterion is applied; (b) <svg height="12.584pt" id="M344" style="vertical-align:-3.29567pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.28833 77.2215 12.584" width="77.2215pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,9.12,0)"><path d="M448 1V51H364C248 51 153 129 140 230H448V280H140C153 381 248 459 364 459H448V509H365C208 509 80 395 80 255S208 1 365 1H448Z" id="g117-173"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,19.616,0)"><path d="M293 -169V-141C218 -131 209 -90 209 -44C209 19 222 85 222 152C222 207 198 255 139 269V273C199 286 222 334 222 388C222 454 209 523 209 588C209 632 218 671 293 681V709C234 709 148 695 148 577C147 513 155 438 155 372C155 337 152 291 64 285V256C152 250 155 204 155 169C156 105 148 31 148 -41C148 -157 234 -169 293 -169Z" id="g113-124"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,24.127,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,29.028,3.132)"><path d="M665 0V33C595 38 568 55 523 124C476 196 422 278 366 366C436 471 466 514 487 540C533 599 553 609 628 617V650H396V617C459 610 463 599 440 558C413 507 382 460 343 400C300 467 263 522 232 575C216 602 218 609 278 617V650H27V617C100 609 114 598 160 531C193 479 239 409 291 325C206 194 151 118 127 89C99 53 67 38 8 33V0H242V33C177 41 172 50 196 91C229 151 269 219 316 288C380 189 422 120 446 81C465 49 459 38 398 33V0H665Z" id="g58-86"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,35.143,3.132)"><path d="M416 501L399 642C356 655 314 665 271 665C140 665 63 582 63 486C63 372 163 325 229 290C304 250 359 217 359 142C359 70 316 25 240 25C138 25 94 125 78 186L44 178C52 123 64 45 72 21C81 16 96 8 121 0S179 -15 220 -15C353 -15 445 68 445 176C445 289 350 335 270 375C191 414 143 449 143 520C143 572 177 627 253 627C340 627 366 556 382 495L416 501Z" id="g58-81"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.085,0)"><path d="M95 130C70 130 46 113 46 88C46 72 54 64 59 64C93 55 121 33 121 -3C121 -41 93 -68 44 -88L55 -117C117 -98 186 -56 186 22C186 91 131 130 95 130Z" id="g113-45"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,45.228,0)"><path d="M393 379C402 394 400 411 393 422C384 437 365 448 348 448C301 448 237 372 186 285H182L193 335C210 408 205 448 178 448C150 448 80 402 29 344L45 321C80 355 114 373 122 373C128 373 130 365 124 330C106 228 76 98 50 -5L57 -12C82 -5 112 3 132 6L172 203C196 256 234 304 254 329C275 355 293 367 306 367C318 367 330 360 342 348C347 343 355 343 365 350S386 367 393 379Z" id="g113-115"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,50.129,3.132)"><path d="M592 498C586 556 582 629 581 675H560C545 656 537 650 510 650H115C87 650 74 652 60 675H40C38 620 33 555 28 495H57C69 539 77 568 89 585C102 607 122 616 205 616H267V123C267 44 259 34 168 28V0H454V28C360 34 352 44 352 123V616H422C498 616 514 608 531 584C542 568 552 543 562 495L592 498Z" id="g190-85"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,55.744,3.132)"><path d="M729 650H468V622C546 615 554 610 554 527V365H213V527C213 610 221 616 297 622V650H38V622C120 616 128 611 128 527V123C128 39 120 34 40 28V0H303V28C221 34 213 40 213 123V322H554V123C554 39 546 34 460 28V0H728V28C647 34 639 39 639 123V527C639 610 647 615 729 622V650Z" id="g190-73"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,62.714,3.132)"><path d="M300 253H71L57 198H286L300 253Z" id="g190-46"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,65.954,3.132)"><path d="M655 0V28C585 35 563 50 517 120C469 193 414 280 360 366C427 469 460 516 481 545C526 604 545 614 619 622V650H391V622C457 614 462 604 438 560C411 511 381 463 339 398C295 466 258 523 225 580C210 606 211 615 272 622V650H26V622C98 614 111 603 154 538C189 482 235 408 288 324C200 188 149 116 124 85C95 47 64 34 7 28V0H236V28C169 36 164 46 188 89C220 148 261 217 310 291C372 193 417 118 442 77C461 44 454 35 392 28V0H655Z" id="g190-89"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,72.485,0)"><path d="M283 255V284C195 290 192 337 192 375C192 436 200 508 200 580C200 696 116 709 54 709V681C127 671 139 634 139 588C138 524 125 452 125 387C125 333 149 286 209 272V268C148 253 125 206 125 151C126 87 139 16 139 -47C139 -92 127 -131 54 -141V-169C115 -169 200 -152 200 -41C200 32 192 104 192 164C192 202 195 249 283 255Z" id="g113-126"></path></g></svg> and strong criterion is applied. The gray dashed horizontal line marks 10% of the unreliable probability estimates. The left part of each panel shows the results of Wistar and borderline hypertensive rats at baseline and stress; the right part of each panel shows the results of volunteers.</div>

Complexity

fig8

Figure 8

Figure 8: On Consistency of Cross-Approximate Entropy in Cardiovascular and Artificial Environments 