A Novel Method for Economic Dispatch with Across Neighborhood Search: A Case Study in a Provincial Power Grid, China

Table 5

Comparison of simulation results ($/h) for 40-generator system (Case IV).

Method	Min.	Max.	Mean	Std Dev
FCASO-SQP [1]	121456.98	NA	122026.21	NA
TSARGA [4]	121463.07	124296.54	122928.31	NA
DE [10]	121416.29	121431.47	121422.72	NA
ABC [11]	121441.03	122023.77	121995.82	NA
IABC-LS [12]	121488.7636	121582.2525	121526.0333	NA
PVHS [13]	121415.4560	NA	121567.0292	94.1498
IHSWM [14]	121416.2652	121855.5521	121553.4208	90.1271
THS [16]	121425.15	NA	121528.65	NA
NTHS [17]	121412.7374	NA	121549.95	NA
BBO [19]	121426.953	121688.6634	121508.0325	NA
aBBOmDE [20]	121414.8734	121568.3254	121487.8532	NA
BBO(Model 5) [22]	121418.70	121954.4	121635.4	NA
TLBO [24]	12996	NA	NA	NA
CTLBO [25]	121553.83	122116.18	121790.23	150
FA [26]	121415.05	121416.57	121424.56	1.784
CBA [29]	121412.5468	121436.15	121418.9826	1.611
EMA [36]	121412.5355	121426.1548	121417.1328	NA
BSA [40]	121415.6139	121524.9577	121474.8823	NA
GA–PS–SQP [44]	121458	NA	122039	NA
HMAPSO [48]	121586.90	121586.90	121586.90	NA
FAPSO-NM [49]	121418.3	121419.8	121418.803	NA
HHS [50]	121415.5922	NA	121615.8544	114.5632
ABF-NM [51]	121423.6379	NA	121814.9465	124.8756
CE-SQP [54]	121412.88	NA	121423.65	NA
ANS-DSP [68]	12141E+05	12187E+05	12185E+05	NA
OIWO [72]	121412.54	NA	NA	NA
IA-EDA [73]	121436.9729	121648.4401	122492.7018	182.5274
NSS [74]	122186.9048	122186.9048	122186.9048	NA
MSOS [75]	121412.5355	121412.5355	121412.5355	2.47E-11
NGPSO [82]	121513.4808	122697.7672	122065.1193	267
C-GRASP-SaDE [83]	121414.621	122245.696	121736.025	166.896
BBO	121669.9298	122446.1176	121865.0181	150.4038
CSO	121440.8040	122092.4350	121637.1868	141.5265
DE	121420.9029	121618.6298	121509.0360	42.6215
PSO	122636.1149	125429.5349	123836.7368	603.6246
ANS	121412.6226	121472.9213	121427.7107	13.6539