Identification of Alcoholism Based on Wavelet Renyi Entropy and Three-Segment Encoded Jaya Algorithm

Table 6

Results of 10 × 10-fold cross validation of four state-of-the-art methods.

FA + PNN [2]	Sen	Spc	Acc	IPSO [3]	Sen	Spc	Acc
R1	86.84	86.78	86.81	R1	90.35	87.60	88.94
R2	83.33	90.08	86.81	R2	92.11	85.95	88.94
R3	84.21	87.60	85.96	R3	89.47	90.08	89.79
R4	90.35	85.12	87.66	R4	88.60	90.08	89.36
R5	87.72	84.30	85.96	R5	88.60	88.43	88.51
R6	84.21	86.78	85.53	R6	88.60	90.08	89.36
R7	81.58	91.74	86.81	R7	89.47	90.91	90.21
R8	86.84	87.60	87.23	R8	85.96	93.39	89.79
R9	85.09	86.78	85.96	R9	87.72	90.91	89.36
R10	87.72	85.95	86.81	R10	87.72	86.78	87.23
Avr	85.79 ± 2.58	87.27 ± 2.21	86.55 ± 0.67	Avr	88.86 ± 1.66	89.42 ± 2.23	89.15 ± 0.83
HMI + SVM [5]	Sen	Spc	Acc	PZM [6]	Sen	Spc	Acc
R1	82.46	86.78	84.68	R1	87.72	86.78	87.23
R2	85.96	83.47	84.68	R2	87.72	87.60	87.66
R3	85.09	86.78	85.96	R3	85.09	90.91	88.09
R4	87.72	85.12	86.38	R4	85.96	86.78	86.38
R5	85.09	87.60	86.38	R5	85.96	85.95	85.96
R6	83.33	86.78	85.11	R6	89.47	87.60	88.51
R7	85.96	85.95	85.96	R7	85.09	83.47	84.26
R8	79.82	89.26	84.68	R8	85.96	88.43	87.23
R9	80.70	82.64	81.70	R9	85.96	85.95	85.96
R10	89.47	82.64	85.96	R10	83.33	86.78	85.11
Avr	84.56 ± 3.02	85.70 ± 2.21	85.15 ± 1.40	Avr	86.23 ± 1.71	87.02 ± 1.91	86.64 ± 1.35