Application of Supply-Demand-Based Optimization for Parameter Extraction of Solar Photovoltaic Models

Table 3

Experimental results on the RTC France solar cell.

Model	Algorithm	Min	Max	Mean	Std. dev.	Significance
SDM	CLPSO	1.0016E − 03	1.4520E − 03	1.1329E − 03	1.0917E − 04	†
	DE/BBO	9.8602E − 04	1.2373E − 03	1.0533E − 03	5.0412E − 05	†
	GOTLBO	9.8627E − 04	1.4071E − 03	1.0796E − 03	9.8773E − 05	†
	IJAYA	9.8603E − 04	1.0019E − 03	9.8934E − 04	3.5283E − 06	†
	IWOA	9.8829E − 04	3.2095E − 03	1.4633E − 03	3.7745E − 04	†
	LETLBO	9.8604E − 04	1.1558E − 03	1.0145E − 03	3.7825E − 05	†
	MABC	1.0154E − 03	1.8145E − 03	1.1980E − 03	1.6722E − 04	†
	ODE	9.8602E − 04	1.4627E − 03	1.0628E − 03	1.1279E − 04	†
	SATLBO	9.8602E − 04	1.0416E − 03	9.9082E − 04	9.3056E − 06	†
	TLABC	9.8602E − 04	1.0311E − 03	9.9051E − 04	9.3740E − 06	†
	SDO	9.8602E − 04	9.8616E − 04	9.8603E − 04	2.5141E − 08
DDM	CLPSO	1.0084E − 03	1.7444E − 03	1.2000E − 03	1.4938E − 04	†
	DE/BBO	9.8589E − 04	1.7089E − 03	1.1715E − 03	1.8756E − 04	†
	GOTLBO	9.8736E − 04	1.4216E − 03	1.1419E − 03	1.2637E − 04	†
	IJAYA	9.8439E − 04	1.1977E − 03	1.0045E − 03	3.6754E − 05	†
	IWOA	9.8629E − 04	2.1982E − 03	1.3907E − 03	3.0524E − 04	†
	LETLBO	9.8270E − 04	1.3936E − 03	1.0648E − 03	1.0259E − 04	†
	MABC	9.8707E − 04	1.2597E − 03	1.0740E − 03	5.8610E − 05	†
	ODE	9.8271E − 04	1.1779E − 03	9.9590E − 04	3.1806E − 05	≈
	SATLBO	9.8301E − 04	1.1634E − 03	1.0024E − 03	3.5296E − 05	†
	TLABC	9.8349E − 04	1.2529E − 03	1.0247E − 03	6.0243E − 05	†
	SDO	9.8250E − 04	1.0271E − 03	9.8822E − 04	8.8518E − 06