Weapon Selection and Planning Problems Using MOEA/D with Distance-Based Divided Neighborhoods

Table 3

Performance (hypervolumn) comparison of MOEA/D-DDN, MOEA/D-DivN, MOEA/D-DisN, and MOEA/D.

Instance	MOEA/D-DDN			MOEA/D-DivN			MOEA/D-DisN			MOEA/D
	Best	Average	Std.	Best	Average	Std.	Best	Average	Std.	Best	Average	Std.
1	0.3609	0.3397	0.0171	0.3522	0.3178	0.0216	0.3429	0.3117	0.0149	0.349	0.3095	0.0246
2	0.4033	0.3541	0.0198	0.3774	0.3331	0.0201	0.3666	0.3159	0.0256	0.3661	0.3169	0.0239
3	0.3609	0.3379	0.0179	0.3402	0.3074	0.0214	0.3642	0.3092	0.0241	0.3674	0.3236	0.0250
4	0.3632	0.2901	0.0256	0.2886	0.2620	0.0164	0.3017	0.2539	0.0204	0.3105	0.2585	0.0276
5	0.4188	0.3528	0.0267	0.3653	0.3304	0.0185	0.3689	0.3151	0.0285	0.3616	0.3250	0.0193
6	0.3283	0.2906	0.0265	0.3348	0.2706	0.0292	0.3457	0.2654	0.0312	0.3325	0.2817	0.0294
7	0.4449	0.4101	0.0223	0.4111	0.3601	0.0301	0.4065	0.3405	0.0423	0.3861	0.3422	0.0292
8	0.4088	0.3572	0.0258	0.3612	0.3199	0.0289	0.3646	0.3118	0.0319	0.3533	0.3086	0.0276
9	0.4221	0.3746	0.0245	0.3828	0.3320	0.0325	0.4064	0.3348	0.0305	0.3996	0.3331	0.0306
10	0.4533	0.3986	0.0275	0.4432	0.3460	0.0283	0.3998	0.3460	0.0283	0.3936	0.3521	0.0280
11	0.4681	0.4180	0.0217	0.4219	0.3590	0.0317	0.4395	0.3697	0.0377	0.4391	0.3746	0.0264
12	0.4622	0.4089	0.0234	0.4314	0.3677	0.0347	0.4406	0.3705	0.0344	0.4216	0.3525	0.0257
13	0.5151	0.4712	0.0247	0.4920	0.4299	0.0352	0.4535	0.4154	0.0278	0.4795	0.4270	0.0314
14	0.4617	0.3909	0.0372	0.4135	0.3512	0.0384	0.4224	0.3418	0.0481	0.4276	0.3418	0.0440
15	0.4156	0.3585	0.0380	0.3714	0.3242	0.0310	0.3778	0.3147	0.0329	0.3793	0.3189	0.0287