Improved Grey Particle Swarm Optimization and New Luus-Jaakola Hybrid Algorithm Optimized IMC-PID Controller for Diverse Wing Vibration Systems

Table 6

Comparison of the control performance obtained by GA, PSO, NPSO, GPSO, DE–NLJ, GADE and GNPSO for linear wing vibration system.

Algorithms
GA	547.4927	6.6374	266.6325	279.099	0.0249	0	10.00	>10.00	>10.00
PSO	137.1411	2.1006	11.5850	10.4237	0.0335	0.0211	5.0000	6.9000	3.5200
NPSO	99.5311	1.4641	7.3532	4.8223	0.0281	0.0712	4.3800	4.7800	2.7000
GPSO	96.4319	1.3808	17.3114	5.3215	0.0281	0.1865	5.0600	5.6800	3.8200
DE–NLJ	241.7747	3.7608	36.8931	38.4890	0.0360	0.0014	6.2200	10.0000	5.6400
GADE	270.6472	3.6972	50.1241	52.3179	0.0358	0.0011	6.1800	10.0000	6.0600
GNPSO	83.3646	0.9969	9.9141	3.7646	0.0281	0.1345	3.9800	5.0800	2.5800

The bold values mean the best values among all the algorithms.