A Selection Hyper-Heuristic Algorithm for Multiobjective Dynamic Economic and Environmental Load Dispatch

Table 12

Optimal compromise results for Case 4.

H	P1	P2	P3	P4	P5	P6	P7						ES	PL	Ec ($)	Em (lb)
1	210.58	10.00	20.90	10.00	239.23	16.59	148.29	20.25	20.25	20.25	0.00	0.00	−51.84	28.48	1919.73	1346.75
2	227.56	10.00	23.66	10.08	285.41	12.60	169.08	13.95	13.95	13.95	0.00	0.00	−43.85	26.40	2132.58	1796.30
3	268.86	10.00	39.37	13.95	293.68	36.57	219.14	12.75	12.75	12.75	0.00	0.00	−30.80	31.02	2841.36	2372.17
4	329.83	10.00	62.87	15.25	323.36	13.60	246.87	23.70	23.70	23.70	0.00	0.00	−20.88	46.01	3156.58	3194.41
5	324.13	10.06	72.78	23.25	345.15	38.60	271.18	16.50	16.50	16.50	0.00	0.00	−12.65	42.00	3719.48	3557.49
6	361.42	10.18	82.90	41.83	366.08	40.23	300.99	28.56	28.56	28.56	0.00	0.00	−3.02	58.28	4307.78	4319.56
7	372.49	10.00	97.98	41.66	399.17	48.63	313.33	23.25	23.25	23.25	0.00	0.00	5.26	56.27	4710.99	4894.39
8	388.33	10.16	96.26	63.62	421.02	51.54	329.52	17.70	17.70	17.70	2.45	2.45	13.50	55.96	5154.90	5446.31
9	403.47	10.02	119.39	52.14	451.51	73.59	354.87	30.00	30.00	30.00	11.66	11.66	22.39	76.71	5728.31	6280.64
10	398.89	10.00	122.71	80.82	489.11	86.33	371.36	23.24	28.39	13.20	20.33	20.33	32.56	75.28	6678.22	6984.72
11	436.48	10.02	136.19	94.10	463.90	97.06	396.79	25.95	25.95	25.95	24.03	24.03	38.66	93.11	6962.08	7475.63
12	460.44	10.00	138.15	98.88	520.67	97.33	367.71	16.80	16.81	16.80	24.88	24.88	45.36	88.71	7194.52	8141.38
13	434.34	10.00	106.95	96.23	480.78	95.11	386.01	19.80	19.80	19.80	24.38	24.38	37.10	82.67	6709.36	7402.29
14	399.84	10.01	116.52	50.93	444.04	71.10	360.40	30.00	30.00	30.00	22.62	22.62	20.29	84.39	5647.54	6197.23
15	367.02	10.34	100.54	46.35	410.98	49.86	324.18	30.00	30.00	30.00	24.66	24.66	5.69	78.27	4865.17	5083.80
16	328.66	10.00	75.10	66.49	357.86	34.55	302.90	30.00	30.00	30.00	15.11	15.11	−80.00	61.78	4341.00	4030.14
17	306.08	10.01	78.12	23.07	405.77	30.02	262.76	25.50	25.50	25.50	13.17	1.78	−80.00	47.27	3898.79	3931.54
18	354.33	10.05	113.64	49.75	376.57	41.42	335.07	30.00	30.00	30.00	0.00	0.00	−80.00	62.82	4814.52	4788.80
19	339.83	10.00	99.48	54.99	421.26	60.38	324.08	30.00	30.00	20.90	0.00	0.00	40.76	55.69	5397.64	5008.34
20	400.81	10.01	130.39	45.46	464.70	60.33	362.39	30.00	30.00	30.00	0.00	0.00	80.00	72.08	5669.78	6485.53
21	405.26	10.00	93.05	81.18	462.29	41.22	351.87	19.50	19.50	19.50	0.00	0.00	80.00	59.37	5498.55	6290.76
22	353.10	10.21	85.54	46.98	387.28	47.03	299.69	13.88	15.35	12.90	0.00	0.00	2.38	46.34	4528.08	4466.87
23	285.78	10.32	54.28	10.36	301.81	22.10	269.04	18.90	18.90	18.90	0.00	0.00	−39.29	39.10	3023.24	2872.09
24	306.56	10.00	36.01	10.21	261.75	11.13	187.17	18.90	18.90	18.90	0.00	0.00	−58.54	37.00	2417.43	2198.29
Total														1405	111318	114565