A Selection Hyper-Heuristic Algorithm for Multiobjective Dynamic Economic and Environmental Load Dispatch

Table 5

Comparison of the results for Case 1 and Case 2.

Method	Minimum cost		Minimum emission		Compromise result		Computational time (min)
	Ec ($)	Em ($)	Ec ($)	Em ($)	Ec ($)	Em (lb)
Case 1
SA [25]	47356	—	—	—	—	—	NA
MSL [27]	49216.81	—	—	—	—	—	NA
EP [28]	46777	—	—	17966	48628	21154	NA
PS [28]	46530	—	—	18192	47911	18927	4.91
PSO [29]	47852	22405	—	—	50893	20163	NA
MODE [30]	46934	18194	48841	18008	47714	18084	15
MOHDE-SAT [31]	46478	18208	50684	17884	48214	18011	14.55
AGB-MOCDE [25]	46230	18295	49866	17927	47589	18075	NA
This paper	44711	22000	51953	17852	47503	18066	9.33
Case 2
NSGA-II [26]	—	—	—	—	2522600	309940	20.11
EP [32]	2585000	—	—	—	—	—	NA
PSO [14]	2572000	—	—	—	—	—	NA
SQP [14]	2519000	343400	2628000	308000	2535000	329300
MOHDE-SAT [31]	2,508,195	334100	2606000	295900	2525000	303900	16.17
RCGA [26]	2516800	317400	2656300	304120	2525100	312460	18
MADM [33]	—	—	—	—	2590500	291960	15
IBFA [6]	2481733	327501	2614341	295833	2517116	299036	5.2
MODE [30]	2512327	301130	2543560	296387	2525841	298344	16.76
This paper	2471526	332300	2598103	291988	2517013	299005	10.85

NA denotes that the value was not available in the literature.