Multisystem Optimization for an Integrated Production Scheduling with Resource Saving Problem in Textile Printing and Dyeing

Table 7

Saving ratio comparisons between manual scheduling, the proposed MSO algorithm, MO-MFEA, and NSGA-II for the integrated production scheduling with resource saving.

Instance	Objective functions	Saving ratio (%)
		MSO	MO-MFEA	NSGA-II
J1	Makespan	15.86	9.66	6.21
	Production cost	33.02	29.53	6.04
	Electricity consumption	18.00	12.44	5.40
	Water wastage	17.17	12.50	6.00
	Processing cost	20.57	12.06	8.51
J2	Makespan	11.97	11.08	9.55
	Production cost	16.92	8.46	5.74
	Electricity consumption	16.42	12.04	5.47
	Water wastage	17.04	12.10	6.17
	Processing cost	17.70	11.80	4.59
J3	Makespan	17.09	14.69	8.19
	Production cost	20.13	12.68	9.51
	Electricity consumption	16.71	16.18	7.82
	Water wastage	14.82	12.03	6.87
	Processing cost	17.14	12.19	9.90
J4	Makespan	13.07	14.20	9.09
	Production cost	13.18	13.67	9.48
	Electricity consumption	12.64	14.63	11.31
	Water wastage	13.04	14.29	7.95
	Processing cost	8.94	10.99	8.58
J5	Makespan	16.28	11.63	8.14
	Production cost	17.57	12.05	7.13
	Electricity consumption	14.54	11.73	6.89
	Water wastage	19.59	19.36	7.38
	Processing cost	16.78	14.65	6.94
J6	Makespan	5.61	2.80	0.93
	Production cost	15.88	10.47	7.09
	Electricity consumption	17.94	11.45	5.34
	Water wastage	21.85	13.06	4.75
	Processing cost	17.31	15.38	5.77
J7	Makespan	15.20	11.70	5.26
	Production cost	16.13	11.80	8.11
	Electricity consumption	15.53	11.99	5.99
	Water wastage	17.54	15.42	12.71
	Processing cost	17.24	13.97	7.76
J8	Makespan	13.73	15.03	7.19
	Production cost	13.94	15.63	8.17
	Electricity consumption	13.74	15.37	3.25
	Water wastage	14.57	15.35	7.87
	Processing cost	13.81	15.60	7.16
J9	Makespan	14.74	12.82	10.26
	Production cost	21.93	15.79	11.40
	Electricity consumption	12.60	11.18	9.35
	Water wastage	16.16	10.61	11.62
	Processing cost	19.58	16.40	8.99
J10	Makespan	17.19	12.67	0.90
	Production cost	16.67	8.48	0.30
	Electricity consumption	17.19	12.16	2.10
	Water wastage	16.83	11.94	10.31
	Processing cost	16.48	12.36	0.37