Research Article

On the Training Algorithms for Artificial Neural Network in Predicting the Shear Strength of Deep Beams

Table 5

Summary of different quality assessment criteria for the best ANN-CG model.

RMSEMAEErr. MeanErr. StdRMAPE

Case 1: Max (R)
Training set12.539.820.1612.610.9935.79
Testing set17.9213.300.7718.190.9936.47

Case 2: Min (RMSE)
Training set14.7310.90−0.4514.820.9935.89
Testing set14.0211.240.1214.240.9926.84

Case 3: Min (MAE)
Training set13.029.880.1713.110.9955.20
Testing set15.4910.60−2.4715.540.9816.92

Case 4: Min (MAPE)
Training set13.4810.200.1013.570.9926.00
Testing set26.4915.41−3.6626.650.9905.79