Enhanced Success History Adaptive DE for Parameter Optimization of Photovoltaic Models

Table 3

Comparison results.

Algorithm	Iph (A)	Id (μA)	Rs (Ω)	Rsh (Ω)	α	BRMSE	MRMSE	SD	NFE
JAYA [61]	0.7608	0.3281	0.0364	54.9298	1.4828	9.8946E − 04	1.1617E − 03	1.8796E − 04	50000
IJAYA [61]	0.7608	0.3228	0.0364	53.7595	1.4811	9.8603E − 04	9.9204E − 04	1.4033E − 05	50000
GOTLBO [62]	0.7608	0.3297	0.0363	53.3664	1.4833	9.8856E − 04	1.0450E − 03	5.0218E − 05	10000
LETLBO [63]	0.7608	0.3260	0.0363	53.7429	1.4821	9.8738E − 04	1.0333E − 03	4.6946E − 05	50000
SATLBO [64]	0.7608	0.3232	0.0364	53.7256	1.4812	9.8604E − 04	9.8780E − 04	2.300E − 06	50000
DE/BBO [65]	0.7605	0.3248	0.0364	55.2627	1.4817	9.9922E − 04	1.2948E − 03	2.5074E − 04	50000
LBSA [66]	0.7609	0.3258	0.0364	54.1083	1.4820	9.9125E − 04	1.1466E − 03	1.3482E − 04	50000
CLPSO [62]	0.7608	0.3430	0.0361	54.1965	1.4873	9.9633E − 04	1.0581E − 03	7.4854E − 05	50000
BLSPO [67]	0.7607	0.3662	0.0359	60.2845	1.4939	1.0272E − 03	1.3139E − 03	2.1166E − 04	50000
CMM-DE/BBO [68]	0.7608	0.3238	0.0364	53.8753	1.4814	9.8605E − 04	1.0486E − 03	8.1679E − 03	50000
MLBSA [69]	0.7608	0.0323	0.0364	53.7164	1.4812	9.8602E − 04	9.9852E − 04	1.8600E − 05	50000
TLABC [26]	0.7608	0.3316	0.0363	54.1154	1.4838	9.8602E − 04	9.8602E − 04	9.1500E − 12	50000
JADE [58]	0.7608	0.3229	0.0364	53.6477	1.4811	9.8606E − 04	1.0833E − 03	1.0900E − 04	10000
SHADE [57]	0.7608	0.3230	0.0364	53.7185	1.4812	9.8602E − 04	9.8602E − 04	2.2200E − 11	10000
MADE [47]	0.7608	0.3230	0.0364	53.7185	1.4812	9.8602E − 04	9.8602E − 04	2.7400E − 15	5000
EBLSHADE	0.7608	0.3230	0.0364	53.7185	1.4812	9.8602E − 04	9.8602E − 04	1.9169E − 15	4000