A Methodology to Determine the Subset of Heuristics for Hyperheuristics through Metalearning for Solving Graph Coloring and Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problems

Table 15

Heuristics ranks per classes, Friedman (Fr), Aligned Friedman (A-Fr), and Quade (Qu).

	Class 1						Class 2
^∗Fr
	1.50	1.69	3.78	4.03	4.08	6.69	2.8	3	3.4	4	5.7	6.25
^∗A-Fr
	627	638	1089	1091	1102	1760.5	293	320	335	428	508	540
^∗Qu
	1.55	1.59	3.77	4.04	4.15	6.81	2.24	2.73	2.98	4.18	5.51	6.39
	Class 3						Class 4
^∗Fr
	1.64	2.18	4.27	4.27	4.82	5.18	2.4	2.6	2.8	3.6	3.6	6
^∗A-Fr
	242	283	403	418	419	568	33	74	78	79	91	128
^∗Qu
	1.71	2.26	4.20	4.52	4.88	5.38	2.07	2.67	2.67	3.67	3.93	6
	Class 5						Class 6
^∗Fr
	1.45	1.55	3.53	4.37	4.68	6.03	1.32	1.69	4.35	4.92	5.05	5.92
^∗A-Fr
	646	651	1144.5	1197	1225.5	2010.5	1306	1345	4112	4211	4227.50	5058
^∗Qu
	1.47	1.53	3.67	4.44	4.69	5.78	1.48	1.53	3.90	4.55	4.60	6.47
	Class 7						Class 8
^∗Fr
	1.32	2.45	3.45	5.32	5.86	5.91	1.47	2.38	3.44	4.21	4.59	5.46
^∗A-Fr
	108.50	171	477.50	578.50	637.50	642	2328	2691	2989	3847	4070	6169.50
^∗Qu
	1.12	2.17	3.65	5.09	5.74	5.82	1.50	2.28	3.27	4.46	4.70	5.43