Case Report

Tug-of-War Injuries: A Case Report and Review of the Literature

Table 1

Literature review of studies and reports describing TOW-related injuries.
(a) Clinical studies

Reference, publicationNature of TOW gameNature of injury or presentationManagement and outcomeComments

1Smith and Krabak,
Scand. J. Sports Med., 2002 [1]
Professional:
World TOW Championship 1998, Rochester, MN
149 injuries:
42% back injuries
23% shoulder + upper extremity
17% knee injuries
NAQuestionnaire survey study. 252 of 990 (25%) pullers completed the survey

2 Van-Heerden and Van-Rensburg, TWIF Research Report Project 1, 2003 [3]Professional:
World Outdoor Championship 2002
Total 9 injuries:
44% injuries to lower back
44% to hip and knee and
12% to thigh
67% did not return to sportReport from a cohort of 544 subjects from 68 teams

(b) Cases or case reports.

Reference, publicationNature of TOW gameNature of injury or presentationManagement and outcomeComments

1 Pawlowski et al. [6],
J. Trauma
1970
17 y/F
? RecreationalIrreducible posterolateral dislocation of elbow jointOpen reduction and repair of joint ligaments and capsule. Returned to full activities at 11th weekNA

2 Pedersen and Holset. [7],
Tandlaegebladet.
1981 Danish
NAThumb amputationNANA

3 Ferguson and Kierkegaard [8],
Ugeskr Laeger.
1981 Danish
NATrauma resulting from tug-of-warNANA

4 Morán [9],
Cesk Oftalmol. 1984
Article in Czech
NAExtensive retinal hemorrhageNAInjury was believed to result from the Valsalva effect during the pull

5 Demuynck and Zuker [10],
Acta Orthop. Be.
1995
16 y/M
NABiceps tendon rupture. Past history of microneural repair of left brachial plexus injuryMuscle strengthening physiotherapyInjury attributed to strength regained following musculocutaneous nerve repair

6Iiai et al. [11],
Kyobu Geka.
1997
Article in Japanese 38 y/F
Formal: athletic meetingBochdalek hernia with incarceration of transverse colon in left thoracic cavityHernia repair with direct suturing through a thoracotomyInjury was believed to result from the Valsalva effect during the pull

7Bruce and Hayes [12],
Orthopedics 1999
21 y/M
Informal: 25 pullers per team Right dominant—transforearm amputation with multilevel avulsion of tendons, arteries, and nerves Mid forearm amputation. Returned to full activity at 8 weeks post-op with below-elbow prosthesis Patient was in the front and looped rope around distal forearm 2 inches proximal to wrist joint

8Chuang et al. [13],
Plast. and Recon. Surg. 2001
Casual—massive TOW game2 patients with type III traction avulsion transforearm amputationReplantation with delayed nerve grafting at 6 months after injuryRope had central trunk and multiple branches and ruptured at mid-point of central trunk

9 LACUNAE [14]
2002
11 y/M
Recreational—supervised schoolyard gameRight palm—finger amputationMicrosurgery to restore the hand with good prognosisPatient was at the front of his team and wrapped rope around the right fingers

10Lin et al. [15],
J. Chin. Med. Assoc.
2003
64 y/M
Casual—massive TOW game Multiple injuries: liver and spleen rupture, bilateral brachial plexus injury, and spinal cord injury—C5-6 intervertebral disc herniationSurgical repair of injuries with discectomy and neurolysis. At 2 years, ADL was partially restored with assistive devicesRope had central trunk and multiple branches and ruptured at mid-point of central trunk

11Choi et al. [16],
Am. J. Orthop. 2008
3 y/F
Casual: played TOW on bed and fell down and injured the forearmVolar forearm compartment syndromeVolar compartment release and surgical exploration. Full restoration of hand function at 3 monthsRupture of flexor digitorum profundus muscle due to traction injury during TOW

12Ye et al. [17],
Spinal Cord 2009
? RecreationalSingle patient with a T10 spinal cord injuryNANA

13Current case—2012
10 y/M
Recreational school picnic gameHigh radial nerve palsy presented as immediate weakness of forearm extensor muscles and wrist dropConservative treatment with wrist brace. Complete recovery at 3 months follow-upThe patient was in position one in a team of 6 and looped the rope 3 turns around the right upper arm