Research Article

Reliability of Chest Wall Mobility and Its Correlation with Lung Functions in Healthy Nonsmokers, Healthy Smokers, and Patients with COPD

Table 3

Intrarater and interrater reliability for upper and lower chest expansions.

ICC agreement95% CIMean diff._AB (SD)SEM consistencyLOASDC

Examiner A
Upper chest expansion0.900.83–0.94−0.33 (0.80)0.881.23–1.892.43
Lower chest expansion0.860.78–0.91−0.01 (1.36)1.412.65–2.673.90
Examiner B
Upper chest expansion0.930.89–0.950.80 (0.08)0.81−0.64–0.952.24
Lower chest expansion0.850.77–0.90−0.15 (1.05)1.451.90–2.204.01
First assessment
Upper chest expansion0.830.64–0.91−0.59 (1.03)1.181.42–2.603.27
Lower chest expansion0.840.74–0.90−0.38 (1.37)1.422.30–3.063.93
Second assessment
Upper chest expansion0.780.66–0.86−0.18 (1.27)1.302.30–2.663.60
Lower chest expansion0.820.70–0.89−0.52 (1.52)1.592.45–3.494.40

95% CI = 95% confidence interval; ICC agreement = intraclass correlation coefficients. Mean diff_AB = mean difference between examiner A and B; SEM = standard error of measurement; LOA = limits of agreements; SDC = smallest detectable change.