A Novel Algorithm to Scheduling Optimization of Melting-Casting Process in Copper Alloy Strip Production

Table 2

Comparison of results obtained by MOABC/D, MOEA/D, and NSGA-II.

Instances	DomRatio12	DomRatio21	DomRatio13	DomRatio31	Max()	Max()	Max()
20-1	0	1	0	1	0.0095	0.0092	0.0090
20-2	0.0227	0.9730	0.0227	0.7250	0.0098	0.0095	0.0097
20-3	0.0256	0.9118	0	1	0.0105	0.0104	0.0096
20-4	0.0588	0	0.0588	0.1500	0.0112	0.0111	0.0111
20-5	0	0.9778	0	0.7292	0.0097	0.0086	0.0097
20-6	0	0.9655	0.0385	0.8409	0.0124	0.0120	0.0126
30-1	0.2143	0.5833	0	1	0.0162	0.0147	0.0148
30-2	0	1	0	0.7188	0.0151	0.0139	0.0126
30-3	0	1	0.0385	0.8065	0.0145	0.0133	0.0145
30-4	0.2000	0.5714	0.0667	0.9091	0.0182	0.0182	0.0164
30-5	0	1	0	1	0.0137	0.0104	0.0132
30-6	0	0.9643	0.0333	0.7778	0.0141	0.0138	0.0126
40-1	0.0455	0.9130	0	0.8462	0.0193	0.0190	0.0162
40-2	0	1	0	1	0.0153	0.0135	0.0141
40-3	0.5185	0.2381	0.4074	0.7250	0.0148	0.0122	0.0123
40-4	0	1	0	0.8919	0.0146	0.0112	0.0128
40-5	0.0435	0.8333	0	0.7600	0.0175	0.0176	0.0162
40-6	0	0.9000	0.0455	0.7568	0.0152	0.0141	0.0144