MABC: Power-Based Location Planning with a Modified ABC Algorithm for 5G Networks

Table 6

Comparison of results obtained for their fitness value by MABC, ABC, MRGA, RCGA, and DE with 50 test numbers getting in 200th-generation time.

Fitness value
Iteration	MABC	ABC	MABC	MRGA	MABC	RCGA	MABC	DE
1	336.569	220.5592	336.569	288.199	336.569	38.4158	336.569	122.4345
2	326.7795	232.8575	326.7795	256.7098	326.7795	38.138	326.7795	122.4345
3	136.3359	178.0451	136.3359	184.0869	136.3359	38.9982	136.3359	147.3075
4	478.0451	263.1525	478.0451	263.0525	478.0451	37.4129	478.0451	147.3413
5	363.8525	206.3958	363.8525	243.324	363.8525	38.8615	363.8525	157.4405
6	399.3313	229.994	399.3313	266.0057	399.3313	38.9466	399.3313	168.3165
7	497.6723	343.9293	497.6723	343.9293	497.6723	38.2377	497.6723	182.6838
8	343.9293	279.6975	343.9293	217.4483	343.9293	39.747	343.9293	138.1339
9	413.9853	217.6088	413.9853	257.755	413.9853	38.792	413.9853	137.7067
10	221.5153	243.5444	221.5153	270.0002	221.5153	41.7116	221.5153	133.2046
11	320.0002	217.1254	320.0002	240.9877	320.0002	40.4955	320.0002	133.0904
12	317.9254	223.4749	317.9254	282.6575	317.9254	42.9836	317.9254	144.4086
13	382.6575	223.1256	382.6575	282.9843	382.6575	45.9056	382.6575	150.9968
14	223.1256	216.3692	223.1256	306.8127	223.1256	44.3962	223.1256	139.5661
15	270.1614	245.5956	270.1614	313.6375	270.1614	38.0587	270.1614	137.1016
16	254.719	185.7675	254.719	204.5175	254.719	39.0704	254.719	176.6061
17	287.0222	205.4735	287.0222	240.775	287.0222	41.1525	287.0222	150.9161
18	321.2165	178.1283	321.2165	185.5978	321.2165	41.6386	321.2165	131.9684
19	378.1283	247.4768	378.1283	265.8708	378.1283	36.8584	378.1283	132.8054
20	247.9118	267.8852	247.9118	310.4483	247.9118	44.0629	247.9118	162.799
21	297.8852	215.574	297.8852	261.19	297.8852	35.4141	297.8852	172.6942
22	220.0042	210.3367	220.0042	309.0168	220.0042	40.118	220.0042	125.2206
23	210.9367	190.0167	210.9367	235.3166	210.9367	43.9276	210.9367	142.237
24	227.8001	197.3563	227.8001	204.8888	227.8001	37.6756	227.8001	160.4762
25	197.3063	229.4653	197.3063	280.4655	197.3063	37.1763	197.3063	129.5167
26	233.043	274.8593	233.043	301.5113	233.043	36.6548	233.043	132.8081
27	301.5113	198.5159	301.5113	224.5502	301.5113	37.8516	301.5113	181.9633
28	291.0059	187.1543	291.0059	237.3015	291.0059	37.8559	291.0059	128.0427
29	321.4146	226.2556	321.4146	331.5433	321.4146	41.3885	321.4146	161.0378
30	257.9592	265.8664	257.9592	265.8664	257.9592	40.9125	257.9592	135.5947
31	365.8994	276.1566	365.8994	330.5423	365.8994	39.8699	365.8994	132.1572
32	308.9495	242.4229	308.9495	289.2582	308.9495	39.6183	308.9495	143.372
33	342.9229	229.6357	342.9229	287.8494	342.9229	42.3116	342.9229	158.5198
34	262.8943	288.9151	262.8943	345.6238	262.8943	40.8357	262.8943	147.5854
35	292.465	125.2196	292.465	197.748	292.465	38.8482	292.465	147.7685
36	397.748	402.1246	397.748	452.8917	397.748	36.3569	397.748	136.2769
37	402.1916	303.3515	402.1916	312.0491	402.1916	43.8927	402.1916	129.7897
38	271.1631	283.7516	271.1631	313.1315	271.1631	37.1562	271.1631	149.7464
39	213.1315	202.5987	213.1315	259.6116	213.1315	39.0499	213.1315	164.2077
40	202.5987	262.1589	202.5987	291.0349	202.5987	40.5539	202.5987	134.8221
41	230.1549	315.8854	230.1549	386.4251	230.1549	41.4009	230.1549	137.6344
42	316.4251	163.4352	316.4251	191.4861	316.4251	39.7959	316.4251	145.1443
43	323.0682	158.5565	323.0682	258.3565	323.0682	40.3688	323.0682	178.4081
44	458.3565	270.9059	458.3565	343.0924	458.3565	39.3066	458.3565	133.0197
45	289.0719	197.5141	289.0719	206.7901	289.0719	44.3265	289.0719	143.9841
46	397.5341	256.4257	397.5341	389.7103	397.5341	39.494	397.5341	125.5549
47	356.4256	169.1989	356.4256	228.2749	356.4256	39.791	356.4256	153.9786
48	214.6505	233.8152	214.6505	248.5624	214.6505	38.7579	214.6505	156.4837
49	333.8152	281.1153	333.8152	374.9021	333.8152	37.5592	333.8152	131.4135
50	374.9021	251.4721	374.9021	279.7401	374.9021	36.0738	374.9021	146.0198
	-test	0.03	-test		-test		-test
	-test	0.029	-test		-test		-test	0.00188