Research Article

Constraint Consensus Based Artificial Bee Colony Algorithm for Constrained Optimization Problems

Table 11

Comparison results of the proposed algorithm with CABCCC and GABCCC (30-).

ABCCCCABCCCGABCCC
BestMeanStdBestMeanStdBestMeanStd

C016.2693e + 038.2442e + 031.6027e + 031.2110e + 041.7983e + 044.2949e + 034.8615e + 037.1251e + 031.4398e + 03
C021.4588e + 033.4858e + 031.0644e + 031.4360e + 042.3061e + 046.0050e + 031.0432e + 034.2680e + 032.1291e + 03
C036.2305e + 038.9104e + 031.8025e + 032.4989e + 044.0926e + 041.0697e + 046.0663e + 039.1298e + 031.6006e + 03
C045.9930e − 094.4008e − 085.5059e − 083.7553e + 024.1474e + 021.9197e + 013.0818e − 071.4143e − 061.4172e − 06
C051.6887e − 022.3190e − 012.7175e − 011.8892e + 053.6283e + 059.8900e + 043.2886e − 023.9283e + 004.4008e + 00
C067.8153e + 023.1383e + 031.7131e + 038.0127e + 049.1573e + 047.7743e + 039.1011e + 024.1485e + 032.6910e + 03
C07−8.9397e + 02−6.0124e + 021.8827e + 02−3.8285e + 02−3.0648e + 025.4701e + 01−8.5701e + 02−7.2916e + 029.0257e + 01
C087.8818e + 001.3153e + 015.0152e + 009.9695e + 001.1728e + 019.0648e + 005.0169e + 006.7117e + 006.0091e + 00
C09−6.0917e − 01−3.0939e − 018.6376e − 011.9915e + 003.0483e + 006.4821e − 01−6.0917e − 012.7884e − 018.0281e − 01
C104.4011e + 015.1414e + 014.9977e + 009.0911e + 001.2839e + 015.0827e + 003.8029e + 014.2848e + 013.3428e + 01