Research Article

Constraint Consensus Based Artificial Bee Colony Algorithm for Constrained Optimization Problems

Table 9

Comparison results of the proposed algorithm with CLSHADE and UDE (30-).

ABCCCCALSHADEUDE
BestMeanStdBestMeanStdBestMeanStd

C016.2693e + 038.2442e + 031.6027e + 031.2011e + 032.5536e + 039.5781e + 025.2924e + 047.3012e + 041.2711e + 04
C021.4588e + 033.4858e + 031.0644e + 035.9671e + 022.3085e + 034.3565e + 034.3910e + 046.1857e + 041.3371e + 04
C036.2305e + 038.9104e + 031.8025e + 032.1618e + 051.2755e + 069.7969e + 055.8671e + 047.3478e + 041.1760e + 04
C045.9930e − 094.4008e − 085.5059e − 081.5181e + 021.9628e + 023.3406e + 015.9023e + 027.7886e + 028.2539e + 01
C051.6887e − 022.3190e − 012.7175e − 015.6912e + 011.4006e + 025.5703e + 011.1546e + 061.6625e + 064.9473e + 05
C067.8153e + 023.1383e + 031.7131e + 032.0262e + 034.1866e + 031.0709e + 031.8111e + 032.2144e + 033.1697e + 02
C07−8.9397e + 02−6.0124e + 021.8827e + 02−1.7379e + 02−4.2553e + 019.6391e + 01−8.4446e + 02−7.0215e + 021.1019e + 02
C087.8818e + 001.3153e + 015.0152e + 001.6420e + 012.9903e + 019.7259e + 00−9.0367e + 012.3797e + 014.1907e + 01
C09−6.0917e − 01−3.0939e − 018.6376e − 013.0878e + 009.9707e + 004.4863e + 004.3277e + 005.8267e + 001.2888e + 00
C104.4011e + 015.1414e + 014.9977e + 005.4461e + 009.9359e + 003.9284e + 002.0576e + 013.5824e + 011.4403e + 01