Dynamic Evaluation of Urban Sustainability Based on ELECTRE: A Case Study from China

Table 3

The dynamic evaluation value and ranking of urban sustainable development in Henan Province from 2013 to 2017.

City	Abbreviation	Value					Ranking
		2013	2014	2015	2016	2017	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017
Zhengzhou	ZZ	12.228	12.191	12.139	12.274	11.936	1	1	1	1	1
Kaifeng	KF	−1.840	0.701	4.013	−4.591	−5.265	11	9	3	15	16
Luoyang	LY	5.670	6.671	5.095	4.383	6.518	2	2	2	3	2
Pingdingshan	PDS	−1.844	−3.114	−2.350	−2.478	−2.470	12	14	11	11	12
Anyang	AY	−0.557	−1.800	−2.033	−3.375	−1.693	9	11	10	14	11
Hebi	HB	2.893	2.945	2.619	3.743	3.008	4	5	6	4	4
Xinxiang	XX	−1.357	−2.576	−3.144	−3.110	2.477	10	13	14	13	5
Jiaozuo	JZ	1.068	1.509	0.154	−0.477	1.557	7	7	8	8	6
Puyang	PY	−3.514	−4.005	−2.780	−0.521	−1.602	14	15	13	9	10
Xuchang	XC	0.093	0.837	−0.104	0.828	1.179	8	8	9	7	7
Luohe	LH	1.573	2.819	1.382	2.184	−1.046	6	6	7	6	9
Sanmenxia	SMX	5.091	5.938	3.985	4.759	6.148	3	3	4	2	3
Nanyang	NY	−2.524	−2.370	−2.355	−2.002	0.898	13	12	12	10	8
Shangqiu	SQ	−7.007	−7.127	−7.953	−6.670	−4.960	17	16	17	17	14
Xinyang	XY	1.664	3.787	2.681	3.316	−4.124	5	4	5	5	13
Zhoukou	ZK	−6.781	−7.277	−6.456	−5.487	−7.214	16	17	16	16	17
Zhumadian	ZMD	−4.856	−1.128	−4.893	−2.775	−5.059	15	10	15	12	15