Research Article
Learning Whale Optimization Algorithm for Open Vehicle Routing Problem with Loading Constraints
Table 6
Comparison of LWOA, WOA, GA, and EDA.
| Problem | LWOA | WOA | GA | EDA | BST | WST | AVG | BST | WST | AVG | BST | WST | AVG | BST | WST | AVG |
| C101 | 242.01 | 311.58 | 279.80 | 245.30 | 327.05 | 288.46 | 259.00 | 333.53 | 294.73 | 243.28 | 323.21 | 288.33 | C102 | 247.62 | 317.52 | 284.29 | 252.38 | 333.87 | 295.02 | 261.09 | 321.98 | 292.14 | 251.17 | 327.60 | 287.46 | C103 | 224.83 | 315.95 | 279.87 | 252.77 | 326.05 | 283.24 | 252.57 | 354.41 | 290.81 | 246.63 | 341.71 | 286.53 | C104 | 245.98 | 308.16 | 280.61 | 268.13 | 338.33 | 296.82 | 258.78 | 314.58 | 299.73 | 245.44 | 330.65 | 292.10 | C105 | 242.79 | 301.49 | 280.94 | 234.54 | 311.92 | 277.52 | 254.55 | 333.01 | 289.48 | 253.74 | 326.57 | 283.90 | C106 | 242.15 | 317.8 | 283.21 | 266.43 | 345.98 | 297.04 | 230.55 | 332.64 | 288.16 | 254.22 | 329.45 | 295.28 | C107 | 248.19 | 306.76 | 279.81 | 261.62 | 310.61 | 283.85 | 248.30 | 316.79 | 282.72 | 255.93 | 328.17 | 294.70 | C108 | 232.96 | 321.57 | 285.42 | 260.09 | 329.08 | 292.76 | 241.78 | 326.56 | 285.77 | 242.38 | 314.09 | 279.75 | C109 | 224.48 | 318.68 | 279.85 | 253.77 | 338.80 | 287.91 | 236.75 | 330.6 | 294.60 | 247.37 | 339.38 | 288.42 | C201 | 328.36 | 406.8 | 373.00 | 357.83 | 420.27 | 389.59 | 343.67 | 413.31 | 384.74 | 342.78 | 420.57 | 382.82 | C202 | 348.97 | 410.72 | 385.56 | 352.52 | 420.19 | 389.23 | 332.24 | 425.89 | 386.71 | 353.85 | 446.74 | 392.55 | C203 | 353.11 | 425.83 | 387.58 | 358.11 | 435.19 | 395.75 | 356.26 | 451.24 | 388.47 | 357.60 | 428.34 | 383.84 | C204 | 337.79 | 415.66 | 379.23 | 354.86 | 431.27 | 384.55 | 294.66 | 448.28 | 384.45 | 337.60 | 456.18 | 399.28 | C205 | 347.33 | 416.55 | 382.22 | 361.29 | 417.95 | 394.90 | 317.31 | 429.01 | 383.39 | 356.92 | 441.02 | 387.02 | C206 | 337.47 | 409.87 | 388.76 | 364.22 | 423.06 | 395.74 | 365.30 | 433.86 | 391.15 | 363.18 | 436.91 | 395.05 | C207 | 336.32 | 418.19 | 382.28 | 359.74 | 420.08 | 388.47 | 340.18 | 422.48 | 385.61 | 337.76 | 431.17 | 391.35 | C208 | 339.42 | 427.92 | 376.57 | 346.28 | 425.14 | 381.89 | 340.07 | 446.34 | 386.12 | 340.42 | 438.14 | 394.69 |
|
|