[Retracted] Meta-Analysis of the Application Effect of Different Modalities of Thermal Ablation and Surgical Treatment in Papillary Thyroid Microcarcinoma

Table 1

Basic information of the included literatures.

First author	Year	Intervention	Cancer type	Patients	Mean follow-up (months)	Data type
Yue [14]	2014	MVA	PTMC	18	11.0	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Li [15]	2018	MVA	PTMC	46	42.0	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
		Surg	PTMC	46	42.0	ARR
Li [16]	2019	MVA	PTMC	168	25.1	CRR, ARR
		Surg	PTMC	143	27.5	ARR
Teng [17]	2018	MVA	PTMC	15	36.0	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Teng D [18]	2019	MVA	PTMC	185	20.7	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Yue [19]	2020	MVA	PTMC	119	37.2	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Zhou [20]	2020	MVA	PTMC	33	23.3	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
		LA	PTMC	34	22.8	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Wang [21]	2020	MVA	PTMC	107	15.1	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR
Ding [22]	2019	RFA	PTMC	37	6.0	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Rong W [23]	2020	RFA	PTMC	198	25.9	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR
Xiao [24]	2020	RFA	PTMC	66	38.0	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Yan [25]	2020	RFA	PTMC	414	42.15	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Yan Lb [26]	2020	RFA	PTMC	211	24.4	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Zhang [27]	2016	RFA	PTMC	92	7.8	CRR, ARR
Zhang [28]	2019	RFA	PTMC	30	18.0	VRR, VRR (12 months), CRR, ARR
Zhou [29]	2019	LA	PTMC	36	49.2	ARR
		Surg	PTMC	45	48.5	ARR
Ji [30]	2019	LA	PTMC	37	16.5	CRR, ARR

Note: PTMC = papillary thyroid microcarcinoma; WMA = microwave ablation; RFA = radiofrequency ablation; LA = laser ablation; VRR = volume reduction rate; CRR = complete remission rate; ARR = adverse reaction rate.