Systematic Review of Chinese Traditional Exercise Baduanjin Modulating the Blood Lipid Metabolism

Table 5

Sensitivity analysis of the effect of Baduanjin exercise to clinical patients or healthy participants.

Before sensitivity analysis					After sensitivity analysis
Comparisons	MD (model); 95% CI	P value	(%)	Method of sensitivity analysis	Comparisons	MD (model) 95% CI	P value	(%)
Baduanjin + routine treatment versus routine treatment for TC in clinical patients
5	−0.56 (random); (−0.74, 0.37)		86	Remove Zhang 2005 and Zhang 2008	3	−0.83 (fixed); (−1.04, −0.62)		0
Baduanjin + routine treatment versus other exercises for TC in clinical patients
3	−0.01 (random); (−0.25, 0.24)		68	Remove Zhang 2008	2	−0.17 (fixed); (−0.45, 0.11)		0
Baduanjin + routine treatment versus routine treatment for HDL-C in clinical patients
5	0.04 (random) (−0.1, 0.18)		73	Remove Zhang 2008	4	0.12 (fixed) (0.06, 0.18)		51
Baduanjin versus no treatment for HDL-C in health adults
9	0.13 (random) (0.06, 0.21)		56	Remove Liu et al. 2006	8	0.16 (fixed) (0.11, 0.21)		19
Baduanjin + routine treatment versus routine treatment for TG in clinical patients
4	−0.77 (random); (−1.97, 0.42)		94	Remove Wang et al. 2007	3	−0.16 (fixed) (−0.49, 0.17)		0
Baduanjin + routine treatment versus other exercises plus routine treatment for LDL-C in clinical patients
3	0.08 (random); (−0.43, 0.58)		88	Remove Zhou et al. 2011	2	0.29 (fixed) (0.05, 0.53)		53