|
First author and date |
Study design | Study selection | Methodology | Interventions |
Baseline |
Jadad score |
Diagnostic criteria | Inclusion/exclusion criteria | Effect criteria | Randomization | Blinding | Adverse effects | Reports of withdrawal and follow-up | Treatment group | Control group |
|
Zhang (2001) [5] | RCT | Refer to criteria of [19] | None | Refer to criteria of [19] | Random and concurrent control | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 3 |
Xu (2005) [6] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [19] | None | Refer to criteria of [19] | Only random words | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 2 |
Lin (2007) [7] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [18] | None | Refer to criteria of [18] | Only random words | No | No | None | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 2 |
Liu (2007) [8] | RCT | Refer to criteria of [19] | None | Refer to criteria of [19] | Random and concurrent control | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 3 |
Sun (2007) [9] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | None | Refer to criteria of [20] | Only random words | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 1 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used auricular seed-pressing therapy | Mainly used the traditional treatment | No report | 1 |
Ge (2009) [10] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | None | Refer to criteria of [20] | Only random words | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 2 |
Li (2009) [11] | CCT | Only reports but not date | None | Only report but not date | Only random words | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 18 months, no withdrawal | Mainly used auricular seed-pressing therapy | Mainly used the traditional treatment | No report | 1 |
Song (2009) [12] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | Only report the inclusion criteria | Refer to criteria of Ophthalmologist Must-Read [21] | Only random words | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used auricular seed-pressing therapy | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 2 |
Zheng (2009) [13] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | None | Refer to criteria of [20] | Simple random | No | No | Mention of follow-up, no withdrawal | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 2 |
Ge (2010) [14] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | None | Refer to criteria of [20] | Only random words | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used acupuncture | Mainly used the traditional treatment | No report | 1 |
Wu (2010) [15] | RCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | None | Refer to criteria of [20] | Block randomization and parallel control | No | No | None | Mainly used electrical plum-blossom needle | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 3 |
Gong (2011) [16] | RCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | Both | Refer to criteria of [20] | Table of random number | No | No | Duration of follow-up: 3 years, no withdrawal | Mainly used auricular seed-pressing therapy | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 3 |
Liao (2011) [17] | CCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | None | Refer to criteria of [20] | Only random words | No | No | Cases of withdrawal, no follow-up | Mainly used TCM heat-sensitive moxibustion | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 3 |
Wu (2011) [18] | RCT | Refer to criteria of [20] | Both | Refer to criteria of [20] | Block randomization and parallel control | No | No | Criteria of withdrawal, no follow-up | Mainly used electrical plum-blossom needle | Mainly used the traditional treatment | Adequate | 4 |
|