Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Review Article

Effectiveness and Safety of Compound Chinese Medicine plus Routine Western Medicine in In-Stent Restenosis: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review

Table 3

Quality of the included RCTs as assessed by the Cochrane risk of bias assessment.
(a)
Quality assessment criteriaDAI GF
2017		CHEN K2013CHEN K2014CHENG SJ2010DAI GF
2010		DAI GF
2011		DENG XD2013GAO XX2012GONG XY2016HAN P2012LI B2014LI CW
2014		LI QZ
2016		LIU LL
2010
Random sequence generation+--+----+----+
Allocation concealment-----------+--
Blinding of participants and personnel++++++++++++++
Blinding of outcome assessment++++++++++++++
Incomplete outcome data-++++++++---++
Selective reporting++++++-+++++++
Other bias++++++++++++++
Overall quality score (maximum = 7)55565545644556
(b)
Quality assessment criteriaLU HW
2014		MEI CL
2011		MENG XL2016NIU XY2012PENG WD2015REN DD2016REN XY2012SHI QJ2014SI XC
2013		SUN QY2016TANG YY2016WANG K2015WANG KL2016
Random sequence generation+--+-+-+-+--+
Allocation concealment-------------
Blinding of participants and personnel+++++++++++++
Blinding of outcome assessment+++++++++++++
Incomplete outcome data+++++++++++-+
Selective reporting+++++++++++++
Other bias+++++++++++++
Overall quality score (maximum = 7)6556565656546
(c)
Quality assessment criteriaWANG X2016WANG XD2010WANG ZQ2013XIAO NH2016XU MT2016YANG TL2016ZHANG PF2014ZHANG Q2013ZHANG RZ2017ZHANG Y2015ZHOU JC2016ZHOU W2015ZHU HB2016
Random sequence generation+-+--------+-
Allocation concealment-------------
Blinding of participants and personnel+++++++++++++
Blinding of outcome assessment+++++++++++++
Incomplete outcome data+++++++-+++-+
Selective reporting+++++++++++++
Other bias+++++++++++++
Overall quality score (maximum = 7)6565555455555