Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine / 2018 / Article / Tab 1

Review Article

Comparative Efficacy of Chinese Herbal Injections for Treating Acute Exacerbation of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Table 1

Ranking of CHIs for different outcomes based on SUCRA.

InterventionCKZ+WMCXQ+WMDH+WMHQ+WMRDN+WMSF+WMSM+WMSMI+WMTRQ+WMXBJ+WMXXN+WMXYP+WMWM

RCESUCRA(%)32.469.485.576.754.519.159.539.555.251.667.838.80
N99136107126482277154
Rank11312712596841013
FEV1%SUCRA(%)43.349.251.96975.147.876.6-41.958.8-20.116.2
N3212446-74-235
Rank8653271-94-1011
FEV1/FVCSUCRA(%)45.856.130.448.273.6352.166.9-58.367.6-30.920.1
N1111445-97-234
Rank85107163-42-911
PaCO2SUCRA(%)32.849.2-59.175.250.754.983.643.43548.751.316.1
N34-122321471140
Rank117-326419108512
PaO2SUCRA(%)45.245.9-60.971.947.45156.149.330.973.853.214.4
N34-122321471140
Rank109-328647111512
pHSUCRA(%)-40.3--7049.358.4-51.348.461-21.3
N-2--243-1151-28
Rank-7--153-462-8
CRPSUCRA(%)45.9-52.260.653-3757.463.351.359.248.821.3
N1-114-1310111336
Rank9-625-104173811
WBCCSUCRA(%)50.4---67--5843.159.6-45.126.8
N1---1--187-220
Rank4---1--362-57
N%SUCRA(%)84.1------66.129.756.5-43.520.2
N1------156-215
Rank1------253-46

N, number of RCTs; , it includes a direct comparison, that is, TRQ combining with WM versus XYP combining with WM.

Article of the Year Award: Outstanding research contributions of 2020, as selected by our Chief Editors. Read the winning articles.