Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine / 2019 / Article / Tab 5

Research Article

Multiresponse Optimization of Pomegranate Peel Extraction by Statistical versus Artificial Intelligence: Predictive Approach for Foodborne Bacterial Pathogen Inactivation

Table 5

Analyses of covariance for all dependent variables and effect of S. aureus ATCC 6538 and S. enterica ATCC 14028 activities.

ParameterStaphylococcus aureus ATCC 6538Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovar typhimurium ATCC 14028
EstimateSEdftSig.LBUBEstimateSEdftSig.LBUB

Intercept9.442.432603.880.0004.57314.30663203203.04301.9731.000−79955.3592595.35
Hour 0−5.443.4460−1.5810.119−12.3211.441−63164529.7870−1.3941.000−128327.77115695.77
Hour 1−5.0893.4460−1.4790.144−11.971.792−20704529.7870−0.4571.000−124081.77119941.77
Hour 2−4.643.4460−1.3490.182−11.5212.241−18204529.7870−0.4021.000−123831.77120191.77
Hour 3−4.423.4460−1.2850.204−11.3012.461−14204529.7870−0.3131.000−123431.77120591.77
Hour 4−3.8593.4460−1.1220.266−10.743.022−8444529.7870−0.1861.000−122855.77121167.77
Hour 5−2.6233.4460−0.7630.449−9.5044.258−894529.7870−0.0201.000−122100.77121922.77
Hour 6−2.0793.4460−0.6050.548−8.9614.8011664529.78700.0371.000−121845.77122177.77
Hour 7−1.2483.4460−0.3630.718−8.1295.6333524529.78700.0781.000−121659.77122363.77
Hour 8−1.0183.4460−0.2960.768−7.95.8633484529.78700.0771.000−121663.77122359.77
Hour 9−0.6723.4460−0.1960.846−7.5546.208422.84529.78700.0931.000−121588.97122434.57
Hour 10−0.513.4460−0.1480.882−7.3926.375004529.78700.1101.000−121511.77122511.77
Hour 11−0.7123.4460−0.2070.837−7.5936.1694914529.78700.1081.000−121520.77122502.77
Hour 12−0.6653.4460−0.1930.847−7.5466.2165114529.78700.1131.000−121500.77122522.77
Hour 14−0.1813.4460−0.0530.958−7.0626.73044529.78700.0671.000−121707.77122315.77
Hour 16−0.0293.4460−0.0080.993−6.916.852114529.78700.0021.000−122000.77122022.77
Hour 180.0963.44600.0280.978−6.7856.977−444529.7870−0.0101.000−122055.77121967.77
Hour 200.2053.44600.0600.953−6.6767.086−704529.7870−0.0151.000−122081.77121941.77
Hour 220.1833.44600.0530.958−6.6987.064−1904529.7870−0.0421.000−122201.77121821.77
Hour 240.0873.44600.0250.980−6.7946.968−1204529.7870−0.0261.000−122131.77121891.77
Hour 260a0600a0
Trial−2.110.73360−2.8770.006−3.577−0.642−1330422.87860−3.1450.003−2175.882−484.117
Hour 0 × trial2.111.037602.0340.0160.0354.1841330598.04602.2240.009133.7412526.258
Hour 1 × trial2.111.037602.0340.0220.0354.1841330598.04602.2240.011133.7412526.25
Hour 2 × trial2.111.037602.0340.0290.0354.1841330598.04602.2240.015133.7412526.258
Hour 3 × trial2.111.037602.0340.0340.0354.1841330598.04602.2240.030133.7412526.258
Hour 4 × trial1.6911.037601.6310.044−0.38353.7661054598.04601.7620.039−142.2582250.258
Hour 5 × trial1.3261.037601.2790.046−0.74863.401755598.04601.2620.044−441.2581951.258
Hour 6 × trial1.131.037601.0900.206−0.94473.205586598.04600.9800..049−610.2581782.258
Hour 7 × trial0.7751.037600.7480.208−1.2992.85428598.04600.7160.077−768.2581624.258
Hour 8 × trial0.5741.037600.5540.481−1.52.649352598.04600.5890.258−844.2581548.258
Hour 9 × trial0.4761.037600.4590.548−1.5982.551256.6598.04600.4290.369−939.6581452.858
Hour 10 × trial0.3761.037600.3630.718−1.6982.451144598.04600.2410.511−1052.2581340.258
Hour 11 × trial0.3581.037600.3450.731−1.7162.432115598.04600.1920.748−1081.2581311.258
Hour 12 × trial0.2751.037600.2650.792−1.7992.34929598.04600.0480.861−1167.2581225.258
Hour 14 × trial0.1111.037600.1070.915−1.962.18514598.04600.0230.981−1182.2581210.2584
Hour 16 × trial0.0451.037600.0430.966−2.0292.11951598.04600.0850.932−1145.2581247.258
Hour 18 × trial0.0061.037600.0060.995−2.0682.0840598.04600.0670.947−1156.2581236.258
Hour 20 × trial−0.0291.03760−0.0280.978−2.1032.04530598.04600.0500.960−1166.2581226.258
Hour 22 × trial−0.0291.03760−0.0280.978−2.1032.04550598.04600.0840.934−1146.2581246.258
Hour 24 × trial−0.0151.03760−0.0150.9880–2.092.05930598.04600.0500.960−1166.2581226.258
Hour 26 × trial0a00a0

SE : Standard Error; df: Degrees of freedom; t: the Student t-statistic; Sig.: the value (associated with the correlation); LB : Lower bound. UB : Upper bound; Trial 1: negative control; Trial 2 : 1 × MIC. Trial 3 : 2 × MIC; Trial 4 : 4 × MIC and Trial 5 : 8 × MIC; ; ; , aThis parameter is set to zero because it is redundant;b Dependent variable: CFU.