Effectiveness of Acupuncture in Treatment of Simple Obesity in Animal Models: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 2

Quality assessment of included studies.

Study	(1)	(2)	(3)	(4)	(5)	(6)	(7)	(8)	(9)	(10)	Total
Tang (2013)[88]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	YES	8
Yan (2015)[27]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	YES	7
Yin (2015)[84]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	YES	7
Ran (2014)[47]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Gao (2013)[86]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
He (2013)[76]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Jiang (2012)[89]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Luo (2012)[90]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Gong (2008)[96]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	YES	7
Yu (2011)[99]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	YES	7
Tian (2005)[102]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Wang (2009)[54]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Liu (2016)[80]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Si (2016)[72]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Leng (2015)[119]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Sun (2013)[121]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	7
Han Li M.M (2015)[82]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	YES	7
Han (2014)[51]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Yu (2013)[87]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
He (2013)[63]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Lao (2013)[56]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Liu (1998)[57]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Wei (2002)[60]	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Yuan (2003)[91]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Zhao (2001)[59]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Chen (2005)[65]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Gao (2006)[48]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Li (2006)[67]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Zhong (2007)[68]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Gao (2011)[98]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Liu (2011)[100]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Chen (2012)[105]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	YES	6
Liu (2003)[62]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
TAKEMASA SHIRAISHI (1995)[113]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	NO	6
Gong (2011)[81]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Deng (2016)[120]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Li (2012)[122]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Yuan (2005)[45]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Yin (2008)[46]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Fang (2005)[126]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Chorng-Kai Wen (2014)[127]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	YES	6
Ge (2007)[129]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	6
Wang (2005)[50]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	6
Zheng (2006)[131]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	6
Yin (2015)[83]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	5
Cao (2014)[85]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Tan (2014)[52]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Li (2003)[92]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Tian (2005)[93]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Sun (2005)[65]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	5
Zhang (2006)[66]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Yang (2006)[53]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Zhang (2006)[94]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	5
Qi (2007)[77]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Li (2008)[49]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	5
Yang (2008)[95]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Yang (2007)[97]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Xu (2007)[101]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Zhan (2000)[61]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Zhang (2013)[70]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Wang (2008)[103]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Yu (2008)[104]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Chen (2012)[58]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Tao (2013)[108]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Huang (2007)[79]	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	5
Zhang (2006)[111]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Fu (2005)[112]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Martin S. Mok (1976)[44]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Yan (2013)[114]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Bo Ji (2013)[115]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	5
Wu (2009)[117]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Alfredo Eduardo Orozco Terån (2003)[118]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Tan (2008)[55]	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Yao (2005)[123]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Su (1999)[124]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	5
Pan (2015)[73]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Si (2014)[74]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Sun (2011)[75]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Huo (2011)[64]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Wu (2008)[43]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	4
Yao (2004)[69]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Xu (2005)[71]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Zhang (2012)[106]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Lin (2012)[109]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Shao (2008)[78]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Hong (2003)[110]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Shen (2014)[116]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	4
Liu (2007)[125]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	4
Wang (2009)[128]	NO	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	4
Zheng (2015)[130]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	4
Luo (2013)[107]	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	3
Wang (2018)[132]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Si (2018)[133]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Tang (2017)[134]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	5
Wu (2019) [135]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	YES	YES	YES	8
Si (2019)[136]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Yao (2019)[137]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Zhang (2017)[138]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Yang (2018)[139]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	NO	5
Li (2017)[140]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	YES	6
Fan (2018) [141]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Lin (2018) [142]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
He (2018) [143]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Li (2016) [144]	YES	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	6
Zhou (2016) [145]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Wei (2017) [146]	NO	YES	YES	YES	NO	NO	YES	NO	YES	YES	6
Wang (2016) [147]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5
Xu (2017) [148]	YES	NO	YES	YES	NO	NO	NO	NO	YES	YES	5

Notes: studies fulfilling the criteria of the following:(1) peer-reviewed publication,(2) control of temperature,(3) exclusion of stress reaction, (4) random allocation to treatment or control,(5) blind method,(6) sample size calculation,(7) compliance with animal welfare regulations,(8) statement of research support,(9) detailed modeling method, and (10) complete testing data.