Research Article

Effect of Foot Reflexology Intervention on Depression, Anxiety, and Sleep Quality in Adults: A Meta-Analysis and Metaregression of Randomized Controlled Trials

Table 5

Mean effect sizes and moderator analyses of foot reflexology intervention.

ParameterResultsEffect sizes (Hedges’ )95%CI

AnxietyCategorical moderators
Outcome measurement tool
STAI9−1.534−2.332, −0.736
Others7−0.894−1.241, −0.547
Reflexology before/after
Surgical intervention
Before5−1.409−2.083, −0.735
After5−1.745−3.066, −0.427
Intervention type
1 time intervention9−1.553−2.190, −0.915
>1 time intervention6−0.849−1.471, −0.226
Surgical intervention type
Cardiovascular intervention5−1.060−1.652, −0.467
Other surgery5−2.340−3.485, −1.195
Random sequence generation
High/unclear risk3−2.401−4.737, −0.064
Low risk13−0.970−1.275, −0.666
Allocation concealment
High/unclear risk12−1.271−1.812, −0.730
Low risk3−1.102−1.668, −0.536

Sleep qualityOutcome measurement tool
PSQI7− 2.021−2.931, −1.112
Others3− 0.853−1.158, −0.548
Participant
Hemodialysis group22.850−4.104, −1.596
Nonhemodialysis group8−1.375−2.119, −0.632
Random sequence generation
High/unclear risk4−2.032−3.033, −1.031
Low risk6−1.424−2.395, −0.454
Allocation concealment
High/unclear risk7−2.085−2.913, −1.257
Low risk3−0.686−0.981, −0.390

AnxietyParameterResultsSlope95% CI
Continuous moderators
Mean age11−0.155−1.790, 1.480
Total length in one time8−0.126−2.217, 1.966

Sleep qualityMean age80.035−0.049, 0.056
Total length of time10−0.346−0.568, −0.124
Duration10−0.256−0.466, −0.046