Research Article

Efficacy and Safety of Acupuncture Therapy for Patients with Acute Ankle Sprain: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Table 1

Characteristics of included studies.

First authorYearSample size (E/C)Experimental interventionsControl interventionsFrequency of acupunctureDuration of acupunctureOutcomes

Yu (1) [23]199930 in each group/30 in each groupAcupuncture; acupuncture + RICE(ice pack) + dimethyl sulfoxideRICE(ice pack); dimethyl sulfoxideTwice a day7 daysEffective rate
Yu (2) [24]199950 in each group/50Acupuncture; acupuncture + dimethyl sulfoxideDimethyl sulfoxideNot reported7 daysEffective rate
Jiao and Wang [25]200448/48Acupuncture + Chinese medicine (shujin huoxue pill + jiejing zhitong tincture)Chinese medicine (shujin huoxue pill + jiejing zhitong tincture)Once a day7 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Wang [26]200527/30AcupunctureInfrared radiationOnce a day5 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Hao and Wang [27]200663/63Acupuncture + Chinese medicine (herbs)Chinese medicine (herbs)Once two days7 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Wu [28]200731/30AcupunctureNo treatmentOnce a day5 daysEffective rate, cure rate, VAS
Ni and Li [29]201064/59AcupunctureIce and hot pack + Chinese medicineOnce a day3 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Sun and Ju [30]201141/41AcupunctureRICE (elastoplast)Once a day14 daysEffective rate, cure rate, duration of pain
Zhang and Zhang [31]201190/70Acupuncture + Chinese medicine (qili powder)Chinese medicine (qili powder)Once a day10 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Suo [10]201436/35Acupuncture + Chinese medicine (yunnan baiyao tincture)Chinese medicine (yunnan baiyao tincture)Not reportedNot reportedEffective rate, cure rate
Du [11]201420 in each group/20Acupuncture; acupuncture + massageMassageOnce a day3 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Li [12]201630/30AcupunctureRICEOnce a day7 daysVAS, Kofoed ankle score, ankle circumference
Zou [13]201620/20Acupuncture + Chinese medicine (sunshang emplastrum)Chinese medicine (sunshang emplastrum)Once two days7 daysVAS, effective rate, cure rate
Pei and Wei [14]201735/35Acupuncture + RICERICENot reported14 daysEffective rate, cure rate
Wu and Chen [15]201742/40Acupuncture + massageMassageOnce two days14 daysVAS, ankle circumference, use of painkiller
Wu [16]201845/45Acupuncture + RICE (plaster immobilization)RICE (plaster immobilization)Once two days21 daysEffective rate, cure rate, VAS
Li [17]201840/40Acupuncture + Chinese medicine (shexiang zhuanggu emplastrum)Chinese medicine (shexiang zhuanggu emplastrum)Once a day10 daysEffective rate, cure rate, duration of pain

E, experimental group; C, control group; RICE, Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation; VAS, visual analogue scale.