Comparison of Different Physical Therapies Combined with Acupuncture for Poststroke Cognitive Impairment: a Network Meta-Analysis

Li, Ruo-Yang; Huang, Rui-Jue; Yu, Qian

doi:https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/1101101

Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine

On this page

Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion Conclusion Appendix Data Availability Consent Conflicts of Interest Authors’ Contributions Acknowledgments References Copyright Related Articles

Review Article | Open Access

Volume 2021 | Article ID 1101101 | https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/1101101

Comparison of Different Physical Therapies Combined with Acupuncture for Poststroke Cognitive Impairment: a Network Meta-Analysis

Ruo-Yang Li,^1,2Rui-Jue Huang,³and Qian Yu^1,2

Academic Editor: Jing-Yu (Benjamin) Tan

Received02 Aug 2021

Revised01 Oct 2021

Accepted28 Oct 2021

Published18 Nov 2021

Abstract

Objective. Physical therapy combined with acupuncture is the current research hotspot in the treatment of poststroke cognitive impairment, but which combination treatment is the best is still controversial. Based on the network meta-analysis method, we evaluated the efficacy of various physical therapies combined with acupuncture for the treatment of poststroke cognitive impairment. Methods. We retrieved diverse randomized controlled trials of various physical therapies combined with acupuncture for the treatment of cognitive dysfunction after stroke. We selected studies, extracted data, and evaluated the risk of literature bias for the included randomized controlled trials. We used STATA 14.0 for the current network meta-analysis. Results. Fifteen randomized controlled trials involving 1288 patients were included, which involved 7 treatment plans that included 3 control treatment plans and 4 acupuncture treatment plans combined with physical therapy. The best treatment plan for improving the Mini-Mental State Examination score of poststroke cognitive impairment is acupuncture combined with hyperbaric oxygen therapy. The best treatment option for improving the Montreal Cognitive Assessment score of poststroke cognitive impairment is acupuncture combined with hyperbaric oxygen therapy. The best option for improving the Barthel index score of poststroke cognitive impairment is acupuncture combined with transcranial magnetic stimulation. In terms of improving the overall clinical effectiveness of poststroke cognitive impairment, the best treatment option is acupuncture combined with transcranial magnetic stimulation. Conclusion. The analysis of all the results shows that acupuncture combined with hyperbaric oxygen therapy can significantly improve poststroke cognitive impairment compared with other combined treatments. However, due to the overall quality and quantity of the included studies, more randomized controlled trials focusing on clinical research on acupuncture combined with physical therapy for poststroke cognitive impairment are required to support the current evidence. This trial is registered with CRD42020200092.

1. Introduction

Stroke is a global problem that occurs primarily in middle-aged and elderly people. The mortality rate is around 30%. Stroke is usually caused by abnormal cerebral microcirculation due to sudden rupture or blockage of cerebral blood vessels [1, 2]. It has a substantial social and financial burden, with high mortality and morbidity [3]. Some patients who suffer from severe stroke have limb dyskinesias and speech disorders, which leads to a decrease in the quality of their daily life, reduces their contact with the outside world, and reduces their cognitive function [4]. The abovementioned factors induce poststroke cognitive impairment (PSCI). The mortality rate of stroke patients has gradually decreased with the rapid development of medical technology; however, cognitive impairment after stroke is still the major problem that affects the life and work of patients after recovery.

To date, there is no clinically recognized therapy to cure PSCI. Acupuncture is a traditional Chinese medical method whose curative effect has been widely recognized, and many clinical studies have verified that it can effectively ameliorate cognitive dysfunction after stroke. In many countries, especially in Eastern countries, acupuncture has been the first choice for PSCI. In addition to acupuncture, some of the common physical therapies that have been proven to have a significant effect in the treatment of PCSI are transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBO), and ultrashort-wave electrotherapy (UWE). At present, there have been many meta-analyses of acupuncture or physiotherapy intervention on poststroke cognitive function, and the results show its excellent clinical effectiveness [5–8]. In the clinic, to pursue a better curative effect, the combination of acupuncture and physical therapy has become a hot topic in the field of stroke. Clinical studies have proved that acupuncture combined with physical therapy is more effective than single therapy such as pure acupuncture or pure physical therapy in improving cognitive function [9]. A combination of physical therapy and acupuncture can be very effective, but the advantages and disadvantages of their combined effects are not known. Compared with traditional meta-analysis, network meta-analysis can be used to compare multiple interventions, even without direct comparisons.

In this study, a network meta-analysis method was used to evaluate the effect of acupuncture combined with physical therapy for the treatment of PSCI using the outcome indicators of the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA), Barthel index (BI), and the total effective rate of clinical treatment.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Registration

This meta-analysis has been registered on PROSPERO, registration number CRD42020200092.

2.2. Literature Search

We searched various databases, including PubMed, EMBASE, the Cochrane Library, APA PsycInfo, CNKI, and WANFANG.

The search strategy used a combination of subject terms and free words. The search time ranged from the establishment of the database to September 2021. The database searches were combined with hand-searching for references reported in the literature. This study focused on the meta-analysis of acupuncture and moxibustion treatment. Taking PubMed as an example, the specific search strategy was as follows: (1) acupuncture [Title/Abstract] OR Pharmacopuncture [Title/Abstract] OR “Acupuncture”[Mesh] (2) Stroke [Mesh] OR Strokes [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Accident [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Accidents [Title/Abstract] OR CVAs (Cerebrovascular Accident) [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Apoplexy [Title/Abstract] OR Apoplexy, Cerebrovascular [Title/Abstract] OR Vascular Accident, Brain [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Stroke [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Strokes [Title/Abstract] OR Stroke, Cerebrovascular [Title/Abstract] OR Strokes, (3) Cognitions [Title/Abstract] OR Cognitive Function [Title/Abstract] OR Cognitive Functions [Title/Abstract] OR Function, Cognitive [Title/Abstract] OR Functions, Cognitive [Title/Abstract] OR Cognition [Mesh] (4) (clinical[tiab] AND trial[tiab]) OR “clinical trials as topic”[mesh] OR “clinical trial”[pt] OR random∗[tiab] OR “random allocation”[mesh] OR “therapeutic use”[sh] #1 AND #2 AND #3 AND #4

See Appendix for specific search strategies.

2.3. Study Selection

The inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) a randomized controlled trial (RCT); (2) the treatment group was acupuncture combined with physical therapy. Physical therapy refers to the use of physical factors such as sound, light, cold, heat, electricity and force (exercise and pressure) to restore the original state of the body by noninvasive and nondrug treatment for local or systemic dysfunction or lesions of the human body. Other design features, such as blinding, distribution, and allocation concealment were unlimited; (3) the control group was conventional Western medicine treatment or physical therapy by itself; (4) clinical definition of stroke: the stroke diagnosis was confirmed by computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging; subarachnoid hemorrhage and subdural edema are not included; and (5) the outcome indicator: MMSE, MoCA, BI, and the total effective rate of clinical treatment. When the index is a continuous variable, the included index is the difference before and after treatment, that is, the difference before and after treatment. If it is not mentioned in the original text, it can be calculated from the given data. The formula is as follows, where corr is usually 0.5:

Trials were excluded if they met any of the following criteria: (1) the research subjects were nonclinical patients, (2) they were repeated publications, or (3) they had unclear diagnostic criteria or unclear related outcome indicators.

2.4. Methodologic Quality

The risk of bias table recommended in Cochrane Handbook 5.1.0 was used to evaluate the quality of the included literature, including reporting bias, detection bias, performance bias, selection bias, attrition bias, and other bias. Each part of the evaluation content can be judged as high, medium, and low risk based on the standards in the Cochrane Handbook 5.1.0.

2.5. Data Extraction

Two reviewers conducted a comprehensive and independent review of these publications and cross-checked them. In cases of disagreement, a third party arbitrated. Data items extracted were title, name of the first author, baseline characteristics of the included study (sample size, patient age, treatment measures, etc.), publication year, risk-related factors of bias (randomization method, blinding, etc.), and outcome data (MMSE, MoCA, BI, and total effectiveness). If the above data were unclear, we contacted the corresponding author of the original text.

2.6. Statistical Analysis

The statistical method of a network meta-analysis is based on a frequency framework, and all the outcome indicators use the random-effects model for data analysis [10]. If the evaluation indicators of this study were continuous variables MMSE and MoCA, the mean difference (MD) was used as the effect size. When it was a continuous variable outcome indicator BI, then considering that some of the literature measurement methods were improved, the standardized mean difference (SMD) was used. If it was a binary variable, the odds ratio (OR) was used as the effect size, and the corresponding 95% credibility interval (CI) was calculated. STATA 14.0 (Stata Corporation, Lakeway, Texas, USA) was used to draw network evidence relationship diagrams, forest diagrams, grade probability diagrams, funnel diagrams, and the corresponding statistics [10]. When testing global consistency, if the difference was not statistically significant ( > 0.05), this indicated that there was no overall inconsistency [11]. This study evaluated local inconsistencies by calculating the inconsistency factors (IFs) and 95% CIs of each closed loop in the network. If the lower limit of the 95% confidence interval contained or was close to 0, the direct comparison evidence was very consistent with the indirect comparison evidence. We calculated the surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA) probabilities to rank the treatment methods for PSCI. Higher SUCRA values mean better results for the treatment method.

2.7. GRADE

Researchers applied the method recommended by the GRADE working group to evaluate the evidence quality of direct and indirect evidence of MMSE in this study [12]. Direct evidence and indirect evidence will be evaluated according to the five aspects bias risk, inconsistency, indirectness, imprecision, and publication bias; and the evidence classification criteria are “very low,” “low,” “moderate,” and “high.” The higher the rating, the closer the estimated effect value to the real effect value.

3. Results

3.1. Characteristics of the Included Trials

The 15 included trials [13–27] were all conducted in China and included a total of 1288 patients. Four of them were three-armed experiments, and the others were two-armed experiments. The included trials involved 4 types of acupuncture and physiotherapy programs, namely, acupuncture combined with TMS (AT), acupuncture combined with HBO (AH), acupuncture combined with UWE (AU), and acupuncture combined with RehaCom (AR). The included trials had 3 kinds of control treatment plans, namely, conventional treatment (C), acupuncture (A), and HBO (H). The literature screening process and results are shown in Figure 1(a), and the basic information of the included literature is shown in Table 1.

(a)

(b)

3.2. Risk of Bias

The included studies were evaluated by using the Cochrane Manual 5.1.0 bias risk assessment tool. All of the included studies mentioned random allocation, one of them [13] described the random number envelope method as its allocation method, and 5 of them [17, 20, 23–25] described the random number table method as their allocation method. One study [16] described a simple random method as its allocation method, and one study [13] mentioned the single-blind method. The rest of the research is not clearly described. There is one study [19] with no pretreatment data about outcome indicators, while the others have complete outcome data (Figure 1(b)).

3.3. Evidence Network

A total of 9 studies reported MMSE, involving 7 treatment options; a total of 6 studies reported MoCA, involving 6 treatment options; a total of 7 studies reported BI, involving 6 treatment options; and a total of 7 studies reported the total effective rate, involving 6 treatment options. Connecting lines [28] show a direct comparison between 2 connected interventions, and the 2 interventions without a connection can be compared indirectly through a network meta-analysis. The thickness of the lines indicates the number of included studies. The size of the nodes represents the sample size of the included cases using the treatment option. The network diagram is shown in Figure 2(a).

(a)

(b)

3.4. Inconsistency Test

The 7 treatment options of MMSE formed 3 triangular loops. The overall inconsistency test results showed that = 0.8858 (>0.05), indicating that there was no overall inconsistency. The inconsistency factor (IF) was 1.07 (A-H-AH), 0.84 (C-A-AH), and 0.52 (C-A-AT). Their 95% CI of IF reached zero, indicating that they did not have statistical inconsistency. The 6 treatment options of MoCA formed one triangular loop. The overall inconsistency test results showed that = 0.3811 > 0.05, indicating that there was no overall inconsistency. The IF was 1.51 (C-A-AH). The 95% CI of IF reached zero, indicating that no statistical inconsistency existed. The other indicators (BI and total effective rate) did not form a triangular loop, so they did not require the inconsistency test. The results are shown in Figure 2(b).

4. Network Meta-Analysis

4.1. MMSE

A total of 7 treatments were compared directly and indirectly, and 17 treatment comparisons were significantly different. Compared with conventional treatment, single acupuncture treatment (MD = 1.47, 95% CI [0.99, 1.95]), HBO treatment (MD = 2.67, 95% CI [1.13, 4.21]), acupuncture combined with TMS (MD = 2.55, 95% CI [1.71, 3.39]), acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 5.98, 95% CI [4.46, 7.5]), acupuncture combined with UWE (MD = 5.82, 95% CI [4.36, 7.28]), and acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = 3.62, 95% CI [3.22, 4.02]) could significantly increase the MMSE score. Acupuncture combined with TMS (MD = 1.08, 95% CI [0.38, 1.78]), acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 4.51, 95% CI [3.04, 5.98]), acupuncture combined with UWE (MD = 4.35, 95% CI [2.97, 5.73]), and acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = 2.15, 95% CI [1.67, 2.63]) could significantly increase the MMSE score and have better curative effects than acupuncture treatment alone. Acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 3.31, 95% CI [1.94, 4.68]) and acupuncture combined with UWE (MD = 3.15, 95% CI [1.13, 5.17]) could significantly increase the MMSE score and have a good effect compared with HBO. Acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 3.43, 95% CI [1.80, 5.06]), acupuncture combined with UWE (MD = 3.27, 95% CI [1.72, 4.82]), and acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = 1.07, 95% CI [0.23, 1.92]) significantly increased the MMSE score compared with acupuncture combined with TMS. Acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = −0.16, 95% CI [−2.17, 1.86]) significantly increased the MMSE score and had a significant treatment effect compared with acupuncture and HBO and acupuncture combined with HBO. Acupuncture combined with UWE significantly increased the MMSE score compared with acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = −2.2, 95% CI [−3.66, −0.74]). There was no significant difference for the other treatment comparisons (Figure 3(a)).

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

4.2. MoCA

A total of 6 treatments were compared directly and indirectly, and 8 treatment comparisons had significant differences. Single acupuncture treatment (MD = 1.78, 95% CI [1.12, 2.45]), acupuncture combined with TMS (MD = 3.41, 95% CI [2.20, 4.62]), acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 5.08, 95% CI [3.45, 6.72]), and acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = 3.84, 95% CI [3.25, 4.43]) significantly increased the MoCA score compared with conventional treatment. Compared with single acupuncture treatment, acupuncture combined with TMS (MD = 1.62, 95% CI [0.24, 3.01]), acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 3.3, 95% CI [1.67, 4.93]), and acupuncture combined with RehaCom (MD = 2.06, 95% CI [1.48, 2.64]) significantly increased the MoCA score. Acupuncture combined with HBO (MD = 2.95, 95% CI [0.82, 5.09]) could significantly increase the MoCA score, and it had a better treatment effect than HBO. There was no significant difference for the other treatment comparisons (Figure 3(b)).

4.3. BI

A total of 6 treatments were compared directly and indirectly, and 3 comparisons were significantly different. Acupuncture combined with TMS (SMD = 1.05, 95% CI [0.45, 1.66]) and acupuncture combined with HBO (SMD = 0.55, 95% CI [0.04, 1.06]) could significantly increase the BI score compared with conventional treatment. However, acupuncture combined with UWE (SMD = 0.81, 95% CI [0.28, 1.35]) significantly increased the BI score and had a better curative effect than acupuncture treatment alone. There was no significant difference for the other comparisons (Figure 3(c)).

4.4. The Total Effective Rate

A total of 6 treatments were compared directly and indirectly, and 4 comparisons were significantly different. Acupuncture combined with TMS (OR = 27.07, 95% CI [1.44, 508.08]) can improve the total clinical effectiveness compared with conventional treatment. Compared with single acupuncture treatment, acupuncture combined with TMS (OR = 6.65, 95% CI [2.28, 19.37]) and acupuncture combined with UWE (OR = 4.63, 95% CI [1.39, 15.45]) significantly improved the total clinical effectiveness. Compared with HBO, acupuncture combined with HBO (OR = 5.13, 95% CI [1.83, 14.44]) had significantly increased clinical effectiveness; however, no significant difference was observed for the other treatment comparisons (Figure 3(d)).

4.5. SUCRA

According to the results of SUCRA, acupuncture combined with HBO may be the most effective intervention to increase the MMSE scores. The SUCRA results were as follows: AH (92.6%) > AU (90.7%) > AR (64.7%) > H (43.7%) > AT (40.8%) > A (17.6%) > C (0%). Acupuncture combined with HBO may be the most effective intervention to increase the MoCA score (AH (97.5%) > AR (74.4%) > AT (62.9%) > H (36.6%) > A (27.9%) > C (0.7%)). Acupuncture combined with TMS may be the most effective intervention to increase the BI score (AT (89.7%) > AU (78.1%) > AH (65%) > C (22.7%) > A (22.4%) > H (22.1%)). Acupuncture combined with TMS may be the most effective intervention to increase the total clinical effective rate (AT (86.3%) > AU (76.2%) > AH (64.6%) > A (37.1%) > H (23.7%) > C (12.1%) (Figure 4(a)).

(a)

(b)

4.6. Funnel Chart

In this study, the network meta-analysis method was used. The different colored dots in the funnel diagram of the MMSE score for the PSCI score with various treatment plans indicate direct comparisons between different treatment plans. The number of dots represents the number of studies. Most of the dots in the funnel chart of this study are symmetrically distributed on the vertical line and both sides, and they are symmetrical; however, there may still be a certain degree of publication bias. There were not enough direct comparison experiments between the other indicators, so no bias analysis was performed (Figure 4(b)).

4.7. GRADE

In terms of improving the MMSE score of PSCI, 21 statistically significant results were included. Among them, the results of “A vs C,” “AT vs A,” “AU vs A,” and “AH vs H” were rated as moderate quality, the results of “AU vs C,” “AR vs C,” “H vs A,” “AR vs A,” and “AT vs AH” were rated as low quality, and the evidence level of other intervention measures was very low quality. The details are shown in Table 2.

5. Discussion

This network meta-analysis involves acupuncture combined with the four most commonly used physical therapy schemes in the clinical treatment of PSCI, namely, acupuncture combined with HBO, acupuncture combined with UWE, acupuncture combined with RehaCom, and acupuncture combined with TMS. Three single treatment plans are involved, namely, common rehabilitation treatment, acupuncture, and HBO.

The results of this study show that the best scheme to improve the PSCI MMSE score is acupuncture combined with HBO followed by acupuncture combined with UWE and acupuncture combined with RehaCom. The best three treatment options for improving the MoCA score of PSCI are acupuncture combined with HBO, acupuncture combined with RehaCom, and acupuncture combined with UWE. MMSE and MoCA are currently the most widely used clinical screening methods for cognitive function. Their scores are correlated with the degree of cognitive dysfunction. A combination of MMSE and MoCA often plays a critical role in the diagnosis and prognosis of PSCI. This study found that acupuncture combined with HBO may be the best combination to improve cognitive function after PSCI. Acupuncture is a core treatment of traditional Chinese medicine, which has a long history, and its applications combined with modern medicine have an objective clinical effect. Western Jin Dynasty’s “Zhen Jiu Jia Yi Jin” recorded that acupuncture applied at Lieque (LU7), Tianfu (LU3), and Yongquan (KIl) could treat forgetfulness; acupuncture at Neiguan (PC6) is an effective way to cure mentality; and Shenmen (HT7) masters “sufficiency of spirit and energy.” The “Zhen Jiu Da Cheng” of the Ming Dynasty also documented that “Shenmen (HT7) removes the mind and nature of dementia” and “Baihui (GV20) treats stroke, palpitations, forgetfulness, and trance.” The archives of acupuncture treatment for PSCI have continued throughout the history of traditional Chinese medicine. Previous studies reported [29] that acupuncture can promote learning in rats after cerebral ischemia by increasing the expression of Bcl-2 protein in the hippocampal CA1 area after cerebral infarction, protecting hippocampal neurons from apoptosis, and significantly regulating the number of synapses and the synaptic ultrastructure. There are also many clinical studies demonstrating the effectiveness of acupuncture in treating PSCI. A meta-analysis [30] was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of acupuncture in treating PSCI, and the results showed that acupuncture was effective in improving PSCI compared with the conventional treatment group, revealing its clinical effectiveness. Because of the excellent curative effect of acupuncture, it has gradually become the routine therapy of PSCI, which is also the reason why acupuncture is selected as the core therapy in this network meta-analysis. It is well known that the mechanism of oxidative stress is closely related to the pathogenesis of cognitive impairment after stroke. HBO increases the amount of dissolved oxygen in the blood, increasing the diffusion radius of blood oxygen, accelerating the formation of collateral circulation, reducing blood flow, inhibiting bacteria, and reducing the intracellular Ca²⁺ concentration. It is widely used in modern medicine [31]. Studies have shown [32] that the use of HBO after stroke can promote the recovery of nerve cells and improve the proliferation and differentiation of endogenous neural stem cells. Combined with the results of this study, acupuncture combined with HBO may be the best choice for patients with a significant decline in cognitive function after stroke.

The best three treatment schemes for the secondary index BI score of this study are acupuncture combined with TMS, acupuncture combined with UWE, and acupuncture combined with HBO, among which acupuncture combined with TMS is the best choice. And the top three best treatment options for improving the overall clinical effectiveness of PSCI are acupuncture combined with TMS, acupuncture combined with UWE, and acupuncture combined with HBO. The BI score is usually used as an auxiliary scoring system to evaluate the quality of daily life of patients. In addition to being related to cognitive function, it is more closely related to the degree of limb movement of patients. Another secondary index the total clinical effective rate is also an evaluation of the comprehensive status of patients with PSCI. Acupuncture and moxibustion not only has a clear effect on improving the cognitive function after stroke but also has been verified clinically and experimentally as an effective measure to treat limb dysfunction after stroke [33]. TMS is widely used in clinical practice due to its advantages of noninvasiveness, effectiveness, safety, and ease of operation. During the last two decades, TMS has been widely investigated to improve blood flow and metabolism in the brain and to affect receptor levels and neuroendocrine function, neuroplasticity, and nerve regeneration [34]. Combined with the results of this study, acupuncture combined with TMS may be the best choice for patients with decreased cognitive function and motor dysfunction after stroke.

While comparing the four outcome indicators included in this study, we found that the optimal ranking of each combination treatment option differs dramatically, so it is difficult to choose the best treatment plan. According to a comprehensive ranking of key indicators, this study found that acupuncture combined with HBO may be the best combination to improve cognitive function after PSCI, whereas acupuncture combined with TMS may be the best intervention to improve the quality of life and achieve overall clinical effectiveness after PSCI. However, compared with these two, acupuncture combined with HBO is more targeted in the treatment of cognitive function.

This study also involves two other treatment schemes, acupuncture combined with UME and acupuncture combined with RehaCom. UWE is a physical therapy method that uses the human body environment to form conduction currents and displacement currents through ultrashort waves and then forms a uniformly distributed shortwave thermal effect, which promotes blood circulation [35]. RehaCom is an effective computer-assisted brain rehabilitation training system evaluated by various investigators. This system consists of a basic program and numerous training items. A previous study confirmed that RehaCom has been widely used in the clinical treatment of PSCI [36]. In this study, although these two combined therapies are not at the top of the list, their ranking is almost superior to single physical therapy or pure acupuncture based on the results of the four indicators. It is suggested that acupuncture combined with physical therapy can usually show better efficacy in the treatment of PSCI than pure acupuncture or single physical therapy.

GRADE rating results show that most of the included interventions are rated as very low quality. The reasons may be as follows: first, most of the included studies are Chinese literature with medium and high risk of bias. Because acupuncture and physiotherapy are difficult to implement blind method, and most Chinese literature does not mention the distribution concealment of patients after enrollment and the blinding of data analysts, the evidence quality of the research results is degraded. The second is that most of the included studies are single-center and small-sample clinical trials, lack of multicenter and large-sample trials, and the evidence accuracy of the research results is low. The third is that the amount of research literature included is small, while the types of intervention measures are complex, the indirect transmission between them is high, and they are small-sample tests. Their position in the probability ranking table is easy to change due to simple factors. The fourth is that the included literature has almost no negative results, resulting in a high possibility of publication bias. Therefore, the overall quality of evidence is not high.

There were several strengths of this network meta-analysis. First, this is the first network meta-analysis to evaluate and compare several different physical therapies combined with acupuncture for the treatment of PSCI. Second, all of the included studies were RCTs, which improved the reliability of the results. Third, we used the SUCRA value to evaluate the subtle differences between treatment plans. Fourth, we used the GRADE scoring system to score the evidence quality of the direct comparison and indirect comparison of the main index MMSE in detail. Nevertheless, this meta-analysis has several potential limitations. First, the number of relevant studies retrieved was too small, especially after applying the inclusion criteria, and all studies were conducted in China, which will lead to great potential selection bias. Second, the included studies did not clearly explain the random allocation method or the allocation concealment. Therefore, selection bias and reporting bias cannot be eliminated, suggesting that the quality of the included studies was not high. Third, the literature rarely mentions adverse reactions. When the outcome indicators of adverse reactions are included, the safety of acupuncture combined with different physical therapies in the treatment of PSCI can be better compared.

6. Conclusion

This study preliminarily evaluated the effect of acupuncture combined with physical therapy on PSCI and the improvement of living ability through network meta-analysis and suggested the corresponding best intervention measures, which provided some decision-making evidence for acupuncture combined with physical therapy in the treatment of this disease. According to the results of the network meta-analysis, acupuncture combined with HBO can significantly improve cognitive function after PSCI, while acupuncture combined with TMS can improve the quality of daily life after PSCI compared with other physical therapies. However, due to the overall quality and quantity of included studies, more randomized controlled trials are needed to focus on the effectiveness and safety of acupuncture combined with physical therapy in the treatment of PSCI, so as to provide standardized and effective evidence-based medical evidence for acupuncture combined with physical therapy in the treatment of PSCI.

Appendix

PubMed

#1(clinical[tiab] AND trial[tiab]) OR “clinical trials as topic”[mesh] OR “clinical trial”[pt] OR random∗[tiab] OR “random allocation”[mesh] OR “therapeutic use”[sh] #2(Stroke [Mesh] OR Strokes [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Accident [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Accidents [Title/Abstract] OR CVAs (Cerebrovascular Accident) [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Apoplexy [Title/Abstract] OR Apoplexy, Cerebrovascular [Title/Abstract] OR Vascular Accident, Brain [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Stroke [Title/Abstract] OR Cerebrovascular Strokes [Title/Abstract] OR Stroke, Cerebrovascular [Title/Abstract] OR Strokes) #3 Cognitions [Title/Abstract] OR Cognitive Function [Title/Abstract] OR Cognitive Functions [Title/Abstract] OR Function, Cognitive [Title/Abstract] OR Functions, Cognitive [Title/Abstract] OR Cognition [Mesh]) #4(acupuncture [Title/Abstract] OR Pharmacopuncture [Title/Abstract] OR “Acupuncture”[Mesh]) #1 AND #2 AND #3 AND #4 39

EMBASE

#5 33 #1 AND #2 AND #3 AND #4 #4 acupuncture: ab, ti OR “electroacupunctur”: ab, ti OR “electro-acupunctur”: ab, ti OR “acupoint”: ab, ti OR “transcutaneous electric nerve stimulat”: ab, ti OR “percutaneous electrical nerve stimulat”: ab, ti #3 cognition: ab, ti OR “post stroke cognitive impairment”: ab, ti OR “cognitions”: ab, ti OR “cognitive function”: ab, ti OR “cognitive functions”: ab, ti OR “function, cognitive”: ab, ti OR “functions, cognitive”: ab, ti #2 “randomized controlled trial”/exp OR “controlled clinical trial”/exp OR randomized: ti, ab OR placebo: ti, ab OR “drug therapy”: lnk OR randomly: ti, ab OR trial: ti, ab OR groups: ti, ab #1 “cerebrovascular accidents”: ab, ti OR “cva (cerebrovascular accident)”: ab, ti OR “cerebrovascular apoplexy”: ab, ti OR “apoplexy, cerebrovascular”: ab, ti OR “vascular accident, brain”: ab, ti OR “brain vascular accident”: ab, ti OR “brain vascular accidents”: ab, ti OR “vascular accidents, brain”: ab, ti OR “cerebrovascular stroke”: ab, ti OR “cerebrovascular strokes”: ab, ti OR “stroke, cerebrovascular”: ab, ti OR “strokes, cerebrovascular”: ab, ti OR apoplexy: ab, ti OR “cerebral stroke”: ab, ti OR “cerebral strokes”: ab, ti OR “stroke, cerebral”: ab, ti OR “strokes, cerebral”: ab, ti OR “stroke, acute”: ab, ti OR “acute stroke”: ab, ti OR “acute strokes”: ab, ti OR “strokes, acute”: ab, ti OR “cerebrovascular accident, acute”: ab, ti OR “acute cerebrovascular accident”: ab, ti OR “acute cerebrovascular accidents”: ab, ti OR “cerebrovascular accidents, acute”: ab, ti OR “strokes”: ab, ti OR “stroke”: ab, ti OR “cerebrovascular accident”/exp

Cochrane Library

#1 (Cerebrovascular Apoplexy): ti, ab, kw OR (Apoplexy, Cerebrovascular): ti, ab, kw OR (Vascular Accident, Brain): ti, ab, kw OR (Brain Vascular Accident): ti, ab, kw OR (Brain Vascular Accidents): ti, ab, kw OR (Vascular Accidents, Brain): ti, ab, kw OR (Cerebrovascular Stroke): ti, ab, kw OR (Cerebrovascular Strokes): ti, ab, kw OR (Stroke, Cerebrovascular): ti, ab, kw OR (Strokes, Cerebrovascular): ti, ab, kw OR (Acute Cerebrovascular Accident): ti, ab, kw OR (Acute Cerebrovascular Accidents): ti, ab, kw OR (Cerebrovascular Accidents, Acute): ti, ab, kw #2 (Cognition): ti, ab, kw OR (Post stroke cognitive impairment): ti, ab, kw OR (Cognitions): ti, ab, kw OR (Cognitive Function): ti, ab, kw OR (Cognitive Functions): ti, ab, kw OR (Function, Cognitive): ti, ab, kw OR (Functions, Cognitive): ti, ab, kw #3 (Acupuncture): ti, ab, kw OR (electroacupunctur): ti, ab, kw OR (electro-acupunctur): ti, ab, kw OR (acupoint): ti, ab, kw OR (Transcutaneous Electric Nerve Stimulat): ti, ab, kw OR (percutaneous electrical nerve stimulat): ti, ab, kw OR (electroacupunctur): ti, ab, kw OR (electro-acupunctur): ti, ab, kw OR (acupoint): ti, ab, kw OR (Transcutaneous Electric Nerve Stimulat): ti, ab, kw #1 AND #2 AND #3 134

APA PsycInfo

S1 AB Stroke OR AB Strokes OR AB Cerebrovascular Accident OR AB Cerebrovascular Accidents OR AB CVAs (Cerebrovascular Accident) OR AB Cerebrovascular Apoplexy OR AB Apoplexy, Cerebrovascular OR AB Vascular Accident, Brain OR AB Cerebrovascular Stroke OR AB Cerebrovascular Strokes OR AB Stroke, Cerebrovascular S2 MA random allocation OR AB random OR MA therapeutic use OR AB clinical OR AB trial OR MA clinical trials as topic OR AB clinical trial S3 AB Cognitions OR AB Cognitive Function OR AB Cognitive Functions OR AB Function, Cognitive OR AB Functions, Cognitive OR MA Cognition S4 AB acupuncture OR AB Pharmacopuncture OR MA Acupuncture S2 AND S3 AND S4 AND S1 3

CNKI

SU = (“Zu Zhong” + “Nao Que Xue” + “Nao Geng Si” + “Que Xue Xing Zhong Feng” + “Zhong Feng”) AND SU = “Ren Zhi” AND SU = (“Zhen Jiu” + “Zhen Ci” + “Dian Zhen” + “Huo Zhen” + “Er Zhen”) 607

WANFANG

Theme: ((“Zu Zhong” or “Nao Que Xue” or “Zu Zhong” or “Nao Zu Zhong” or “Que Xue Xing Zu Zhong” or “Zhong Feng”) and “Ren Zhi” and (“Zhen Jiu” or “Dian Zhen” or “Zhen Ci” or “Huo Zhen” or “Er Zhen”)) 866

Data Availability

This paper is a meta-analysis, so all the original data in this paper can be extracted from the cited references mentioned in this paper.

Not applicable.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.

Authors’ Contributions

Li wrote the manuscript. Yu revised the manuscript. Huang participated in data collation. All the authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript.

Acknowledgments

This study was supported by the Sichuan Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine (2016Z001).

References

V. L. Feigin, C. M. Lawes, D. A. Bennett, and C. S. Anderson, “Stroke epidemiology: A review of population-based studies of incidence, prevalence, and case-fatality in the late 20th century,” The Lancet Neurology, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 43–53, 2003.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
H. Shim, “Vascular cognitive impairment and post-stroke cognitive deficits,” Current Neurology and Neuroscience Reports, vol. 14, no. 1, p. 418, 2014.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
P. L. Kolominsky-Rabas, P. U. Heuschmann, D. Marschall et al., “Lifetime cost of ischemic stroke in Germany: Results and national projections from a population-based stroke registry,” Stroke, vol. 37, no. 5, pp. 1179–1183, 2006.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. Qian, L. Ding, L. Cheng et al., “Early biomarkers for post-stroke cognitive impairment,” Journal of Neurology, vol. 259, no. 10, pp. 2111–2118, 2012.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. Kuang, W. Fan, J. Hu et al., “Acupuncture for post-stroke cognitive impairment: A systematic review and meta-analysis,” Acupuncture in Medicine, vol. 39, no. 6, 2021.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. Zhou, Y. Wang, J. Qiao, Q. M. Wang, and X. Luo, “Acupuncture for improving cognitive impairment after stroke: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials,” Frontiers in Psychology, vol. 11, Article ID 549265, 2020.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
M. Liu, G. Bao, L. Bai, and E. Yu, “The role of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of cognitive impairment in stroke patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis,” Science Progress, vol. 104, no. 2, 2021.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
Q. You, L. Li, S.-q. Xiong et al., “Meta-analysis on the efficacy and safety of hyperbaric oxygen as adjunctive therapy for vascular dementia,” Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience, vol. 11, p. 86, 2019.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
J. W. Zhou, A. R. Zhang, L. Qiu et al., “Cognitive impairment in earthquake brain injury treated with comprehensive program of acupuncture and rehabilitation: a randomized controlled trial,” Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 105–109, 2014 Feb.
View at: Google Scholar
A. Chaimani, J. P. T. Higgins, D. Mavridis, P. Spyridonos, and G. Salanti, “Graphical tools for network meta-analysis in STATA,” PLoS One, vol. 8, no. 10, Article ID e76654, 2013.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
G. Valkenhoef, S. Dias, A. E. Ades, and N. J. Welton, “Automated generation of node‐splitting models for assessment of inconsistency in network meta‐analysis,” Research Synthesis Methods, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 80–93, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
N. Yang, S. Q. Xiao, and Q. Zhou, “An introduction of principles and methods of applying GRADE to network meta-analysis,” Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. 598–603, 2016.
View at: Google Scholar
C. Jiang, S. Yang, and J. Tao, “Clinical efficacy of acupuncture treatment in combination with RehaCom cognitive training for improving cognitive function in stroke: A 2 × 2 factorial design randomized controlled trial,” Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, vol. 17, no. 12, pp. 1114–1122, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
Z. X. Deng, “Observation on the clinical effect of scalp acupuncture combined with transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of cognitive impairment after stroke,” Journal of Bethune Military Medical College, vol. 13, no. 01, pp. 105-106, 2015.
View at: Google Scholar
L. J. Gao, C. X. Liu, and L. H. Liao, “Clinical study on the treatment of cognitive dysfunction in patients with stroke by quanjing acupuncture combined with rTMS,” Chinese Manipulation Rehabilitation Medicine, vol. 10, no. 14, pp. 43–45+47, 2019.
View at: Google Scholar
L. Liang and H. S. Ye, “Observation on the effect of hyperbaric oxygen combined with scalp and body acupuncture on 62 patients with stroke,” Shenzhen Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, vol. 20, no. 06, pp. 377–379, 2010.
View at: Google Scholar
N. Liu and X. D. Wu, “Acupuncture combined with ultrashort wave physiotherapy for post-stroke shoulder-hand syndrome,” Chinese Journal of Geriatric Care, vol. 17, no. 02, pp. 50–53, 2019.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. F. Ma, Z. X. Han, and Y. H. Wu, “Effect of hyperbaric oxygen combined with electroacupuncture at Siguan acupoint on early cognitive impairment in stroke patients,” Surgical Research and New Technique, vol. 7, no. 01, pp. 38–40, 2018.
View at: Google Scholar
M. H. Wang, “Hyperbaric oxygen combined with electric acupuncture in the treatment of cognitive dysfunction after craniocerebral injury for 43 cases,” Chinese Medicine Modern Distance Education of China, vol. 14, no. 24, pp. 89-90, 2016.
View at: Google Scholar
H. B. Xie, A. P. Zhang, and T. Y. Liu, “Effects of ultrashort wave physical therapy combined with acupuncture and exercise rehabilitation prescription on spontaneous pain of shoulder-hand syndrome and upper limb motor function after stroke,” Journal of Emergency in Traditional Chinese Medicine, vol. 27, no. 04, pp. 665–668, 2018.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. K. Yang, F. Zhang, and X. H. Zhou, “The effect of hyperbaric oxygen combined with acupuncture on cognitive function of patients with cerebral infarction in recovery period,” Guide of China Medicine, vol. 18, no. 17, pp. 7–9, 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
T. Y. Yu and S. Y. Zheng, “Effect of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with acupuncture therapy on improving the cognitive dysfunction of stroke patients,” Chinese Journal of Gerontology, vol. 38, no. 22, pp. 5416–5418, 2018.
View at: Google Scholar
S. X. Zhang, “Clinical observation on 60 cases of cerebral infarction treated with acupuncture and hyperbaric oxygen,” Guiding Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Pharmacology, vol. 18, no. 06, pp. 60-61, 2012.
View at: Google Scholar
D. Zhang, “Effects of electro-acupuncture combined with hyperbaric oxygen on cognitive ability and plasma homocyste inpatients with dementia after cerebral infarction,” Chinese Journal of Primary Medicine and Pharmacy, vol. 20, no. 21, pp. 3223–3225, 2013.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. Zhang, W. J. Zhang, and Z. J. Meng, “Effect of acupuncture and hyperbaric oxygen therapy on motor function and cognitive function of patients with acute ischemic stroke,” Guiding Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Pharmacology, vol. 22, no. 19, pp. 61–63, 2016.
View at: Google Scholar
C. Jiang, “Acupuncture combined with Rehacom training and rehabilitation program to improve cognitive dysfunction after stroke: Rs-fMRI study,” Fujian University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Fuzhou, China, 2015.
View at: Google Scholar
H. X. Bie and X. Y. Wang, “Tiaoshen tongluo acupuncture combined with repeated transcranial magnetic stimulation to treat 36 cases of mild cognitive dysfunction after stroke,” Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, vol. 52, no. 04, pp. 335–337, 2011.
View at: Google Scholar
Z.-Q. Lin, H.-Z. Zhang, G.-G. Luo et al., “Comparison of 3 treatment methods for distal tibial fractures: a network meta-analysis,” Medical Science Monitor, vol. 25, pp. 7480–7487, 2019.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. P. Peng, Y. Peng, and D. J. Zhu, “The effect of acupuncture on Bcl-2 of hippocampal neurons in ischemia side and the relationship between these effects and learning and memory in cerebral infarction rats,” Medical Journal of West China, vol. 22, no. 12, pp. 2204–2206, 2010.
View at: Google Scholar
L. Zhou, Y. Wang, J. Qiao, Q. M. Wang, and X. Luo, “Acupuncture for improving cognitive impairment after stroke: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials,” Frontiers in Psychology, vol. 11, Article ID 549265, 2020.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. Sun, H. Strelow, and G. Mies, “Oxygen therapy improves energy metabolism in focal cerebral ischemia,” Brain Research, vol. 1415, pp. 103–108, 2011.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. B. Rockswold, G. L. Rockswold, and J. M. Vargo, “Effects of hyperbaric oxygenation therapy on cerebral metabolism and intracranial pressure in severely brain Injured patients,” Journal of Neurosurgery, vol. 94, no. 5, pp. 404–411, 2010.
View at: Google Scholar
CHEN and C. A. I. Shu-qi, “Altered brain regional homogeneity following contralateral acupuncture at quchi (LI 11) and zusanli (ST 36) in ischemic stroke patients with left hemiplegia: an fMRI study],” Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine, vol. 26, no. 01, pp. 22–27, 2020.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
M. S. George and G. Aston-Jones, “Noninvasive techniques for probing neurocircuitry and treating illness: vagus nerve stimulation(VNS), transcranial magnetic stimulation(TMS) and transcranial direct current stimulation(tDCS),” Neuropsychopharmacology, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 301–316, 2010.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
Q. G. Li and H. Z. Li, “Research progress of ultrashort wave in the treatment of clinical diseases,” Chinese Community Doctors, vol. 13, no. 34, pp. 17-18, 2011.
View at: Google Scholar
H. C. Zhou, P. D. Zhang, L. S. Chen et al., “Observation on the effect of computer-assisted cognitive training on vascular cognitive impairment,” Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, vol. 27, no. 06, pp. 551–553, 2012.
View at: Google Scholar

Copyright

Copyright © 2021 Ruo-Yang Li et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

PDF Download Citation

Download other formats

Order printed copies

Views

425

Downloads

690

Citations