Research Article

Summary and Analysis of Relevant Evidence for Nondrug Nursing Programs in Neonatal Operational Pain Management

Table 4

Evidence description and summary.

Intervention measureEvidence contentLevel of evidenceRecommended level

Breast feeding(1) For neonates, providing breast milk through the nipple or syringe is as effective as using glucose and sucrose [14, 15, 20]Level 1Grade A
(2) For neonates, the smell of breast milk has an analgesic effect [13, 14]Level 1Grade B
(3) Breast feeding should be the first choice for neonatal single operational pain, followed by glucose, sucrose, and other substitutes [20]Level 1Grade A
(4) In full-term neonates, breast feeding has a lower pain response compared with posture, shaking, and mother holding [15]Level 1Grade A
(5) The sweetener of breast feeding is lactose secreted by the mother, which is different from glucose and sucrose [16]Level 1Grade A
Sweetener(6) For neonates, the recommended dose of sucrose for analgesia is 12–120 mg [18]Level 1Grade A
(7) It is recommended that sucrose be taken orally at least 2 min before painful operation [18]Level 1Grade A
(8) Glucose in 20%–30% solution can replace sucrose for analgesic treatment [14]Level 1Grade A
(9) Sweeteners are suitable for infants <3 months [16]Level 1Grade A
(10) Sucrose is advised to be used with caution in preterm infants <32 weeks of pregnancy, unstable condition, and mechanically ventilated neonates [18]Level 1Grade A
KMC(11) KMC can relieve the pain of premature and full-term infants to a certain extent [15]Level 1Grade A
(12) KMC can be performed for neonates who are accustomed to nonbreast feeding [13]Level 1Grade A
(13) Low-birth-weight infants should implement KMC as soon as possible and as long as possible after birth [21]Level 5Grade B
(14) In neonatal KMC, there is no difference in the analgesic effect between mothers and others [19]Level 1Grade A
(15) For neonates, KMC should choose a comfortable position and should be combined with slapping or shaking actions after vaccination [13]Level 1Grade A
Sensory stimulation(16) When all sensory stimulation are used, the analgesic effect is better than that of single oral sucrose [15]Level 1Grade A
(17) The upper limb massage can relieve the pain of neonates [16]Level 1Grade A
(18) During the heel blood collection of premature infants, the pain can be alleviated by playing the same music that the mother heard during pregnancy [15]Level 2Grade B
(19) During neonatal vaccination, the analgesic effect of taste stimulation combined with visual stimulation is better [13]Level 1Grade A
Nonnutritive sucking (NNS)(20) Sweeteners and NNS play a synergistic role in neonatal analgesia [18]Level 1Grade A