Laparoscopic Reversal of Hartmann’s Procedure: State of the Art 20 Years after the First Reported Case

Table 2

Operative data.

Author	Year	Pz	Hinchey class	Mean days after first operation	Position of first trocar			Mean operative time	Conversion	Causes
					R; Q	U; T	CS			RS	EA	OT
Anderson et al. [4]	1993	2		240				—	0
Gorey et al. [10]	1993	1						95	0
Sosa et al. [11]	1994	18						230	4
Costantino and Mukalian [12]	1994	3		180	3			148	0
Vernava III et al. [13]	1995	2						195	0
Regadas et al. [14]	1996	20		80				130	3	1	1	1
Macpherson et al. [15]	1996	12		225		10		169	0
Delgado et al. [16]	1998	11		50				144	1
Köhler et al. [17]	1999	18		160				114	2
Holland et al. [18]	2002	4		83.6		4		146	1	1
Vacher et al. [19]	2002	38		136		14	24		6
Mutter et al. [20]	2004	3						180	0
Rosen et al. [8]	2005	22		168				158	2			2
Khaikin et al. [21]	2006	27		255	6		21	226	4	1	3
Golash [22]	2006	12		130	12			90	2		2
Slawik and Dixon [23]	2007	28		330	28			80	1		1
Faure et al. [24]	2007	14	III-IV	180		14		143	2
Haughn et al. [25]	2008	61		240				154	8
Carus et al. [5]	2008	28		95		28		69	5		5
Petersen et al. [26]	2009	71		120				164	9		9
Mazeh et al. [27]	2009	41	III-IV	187	41			193	8		3	5
Chouillard et al. [28]	2009	44		166		44		195	4
Agaba et al. [29]	2009	7	III-IV	95		7		189	0
Svenningsen et al. [30]	2010	21		180				285	1
Caselli et al. [31]	2010	30	III-IV	213		30		172	3		1	2
Di Carlo et al. [32]	2011	3	IV	92		3		96	0
Huynh et al. [33]	2011	28		135		28		166	0
Leroy et al. [34]	2011	42	III-IV	204	42			117	4		1	3
De’angelis et al. [35]	2013	28	III-IV	134.8			18	171.1	0
Maitra et al. [36]	2013	45			45			164.1	13	1	13
Total		684		4079.4	177	182	39	4383.2	83	4	39	13
Mean		22.8		163.2	25.2	18.2	13	156.6	2.8	1	3.9	2.6
Range		1–71		50–330	3–45	3–44	18–24	69–285	0–13	1	1–13	1–5

Legend: RQ: right upper quadrant; UT: umbilical trocars; CS: colostomy site; RS: rectal stump; EA: extensive adhesions; OT: other.