Research Article

Flight Loads Prediction of High Aspect Ratio Wing Aircraft Using Multibody Dynamics

Table 3

Comparison of the first five natural frequencies of the free-free RHS wing.

Mode description3D FEMMethod AMethod BMethod C
Frequency [Hz]Frequency [Hz]Error [%]Frequency [Hz]Error [%]Frequency [Hz]Error [%]

1st bending2.4212.363−2.40%2.412−0.37%2.405−0.66%
2nd bending5.5935.405−3.36%5.553−0.72%5.527−1.18%
1st in-plane bending7.6947.417−3.60%7.628−0.86%7.599−1.23%
3rd bending10.2049.779−4.17%10.109−0.93%10.064−1.37%
1st torsion15.35013.062−14.91%14.536−5.30%13.609−11.34%