A Comparison of Genetic Programming with Genetic Algorithms for Wire Antenna Design

<table>The tree structure representing the function <svg height="16.4125" id="M24" style="vertical-align:-3.3907pt" version="1.1" viewbox="0 0 272.14999 16.4125" width="272.14999" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
<g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,.062,12.138)"><path d="M457 488l-30 -3q-17 148 -131 148q-53 0 -84.5 -34.5t-31.5 -82.5q0 -42 25.5 -72t74.5 -62l33 -22q63 -42 95 -85t32 -102q0 -84 -67 -137t-163 -53q-58 0 -113 22t-70 43l-4 152l27 4q4 -32 15 -62.5t31 -59.5t53.5 -47t76.5 -18q56 0 92 35t36 96q0 39 -25 70t-78 68
l-31 22q-32 23 -53.5 41.5t-45 57t-23.5 77.5q0 82 58 132.5t156 50.5q46 0 101 -17l18.5 -6t17 -6t8.5 -3q-4 -55 0 -147z" id="x1D446"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,8.222,12.138)"><path d="M300 -147l-18 -23q-106 71 -159 185.5t-53 254.5v1q0 139 53 252.5t159 186.5l18 -24q-74 -62 -115.5 -173.5t-41.5 -242.5q0 -130 41.5 -242.5t115.5 -174.5z" id="x28"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,14.103,12.138)"><path d="M484 24v-24h-241v24q45 3 45 20q0 16 -33 64q-23 32 -42 63l-16 -20q-64 -76 -64 -103q0 -21 50 -24v-24h-169v24q27 1 49 19q20 16 64 74l43 56q8 9 11 14t11 14l-128 197q-15 23 -24 29.5t-28 9.5v24h250v-24q-47 -2 -47 -19q0 -22 58 -98q7 -8 13 -17l36 46
q38 50 38 64q0 11 -6.5 15.5t-24.5 6.5l-20 2v24h168v-24q-45 -8 -70 -39l-101 -126l148 -228q7 -12 30 -20z" id="x1D431"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.012,-0,0,-.012,22.6,16.212)"><path d="M241 635q53 0 94 -28.5t63.5 -76t33.5 -102.5t11 -116q0 -58 -11 -112.5t-34 -103.5t-63.5 -78.5t-94.5 -29.5t-95 28t-64.5 75t-34.5 102.5t-11 118.5q0 58 11.5 112.5t34.5 103t64.5 78t95.5 29.5zM238 602q-32 0 -55.5 -25t-35.5 -68t-17.5 -91t-5.5 -105
q0 -76 10 -138.5t37 -107.5t69 -45q32 0 55.5 25t35.5 68.5t17.5 91.5t5.5 105t-5.5 105.5t-18 92t-36 68t-56.5 24.5z" id="x30"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,28.938,12.138)"><path d="M95 130q31 0 61 -30t30 -78q0 -53 -38 -87.5t-93 -51.5l-11 29q77 31 77 85q0 26 -17.5 43t-44.5 24q-4 0 -8.5 6.5t-4.5 17.5q0 18 15 30t34 12z" id="x2C"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,35.635,12.138)"><path d="M434 650l-5 -28q-60 -8 -75 -20.5t-25 -69.5l-71 -395q-20 -107 -57.5 -168t-106.5 -94q-40 -18 -61 -20l-10 32q77 23 113 108q21 50 41 160l68 377q10 57 -1.5 69.5t-76.5 20.5l6 28h261z" id="x1D43D"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,43.403,12.138)"><path d="M300 -147l-18 -23q-106 71 -159 185.5t-53 254.5v1q0 139 53 252.5t159 186.5l18 -24q-74 -62 -115.5 -173.5t-41.5 -242.5q0 -130 41.5 -242.5t115.5 -174.5z" id="x28"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,49.285,12.138)"><path d="M1004 650l-6 -29q-54 -6 -71 -19.5t-51 -74.5l-271 -539h-33l-98 506h-3l-258 -506h-30l-78 532q-10 67 -21.5 80t-66.5 21l6 29h241l-8 -29l-26 -5q-34 -6 -41 -16t-3 -47l59 -425h4l251 510h31l102 -510h2q150 299 198 423q14 40 8.5 48.5t-47.5 16.5l-28 5l7 29h231z
" id="x1D44A"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,66.556,12.138)"><path d="M300 -147l-18 -23q-106 71 -159 185.5t-53 254.5v1q0 139 53 252.5t159 186.5l18 -24q-74 -62 -115.5 -173.5t-41.5 -242.5q0 -130 41.5 -242.5t115.5 -174.5z" id="x28"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,72.437,12.138)"><path d="M484 24v-24h-241v24q45 3 45 20q0 16 -33 64q-23 32 -42 63l-16 -20q-64 -76 -64 -103q0 -21 50 -24v-24h-169v24q27 1 49 19q20 16 64 74l43 56q8 9 11 14t11 14l-128 197q-15 23 -24 29.5t-28 9.5v24h250v-24q-47 -2 -47 -19q0 -22 58 -98q7 -8 13 -17l36 46
q38 50 38 64q0 11 -6.5 15.5t-24.5 6.5l-20 2v24h168v-24q-45 -8 -70 -39l-101 -126l148 -228q7 -12 30 -20z" id="x1D431"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.012,-0,0,-.012,80.95,16.212)"><path d="M384 0h-275v27q67 5 81.5 18.5t14.5 68.5v385q0 38 -7.5 47.5t-40.5 10.5l-48 2v24q85 15 178 52v-521q0 -55 14.5 -68.5t82.5 -18.5v-27z" id="x31"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,87.288,12.138)"><path d="M95 130q31 0 61 -30t30 -78q0 -53 -38 -87.5t-93 -51.5l-11 29q77 31 77 85q0 26 -17.5 43t-44.5 24q-4 0 -8.5 6.5t-4.5 17.5q0 18 15 30t34 12z" id="x2C"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,93.985,12.138)"><path d="M609 650l-19 -162l-30 -2q2 69 -14 94q-9 18 -28.5 26t-74.5 8h-88q-30 0 -37 -6.5t-12 -36.5l-41 -212h103q48 0 69 5.5t32 19t26 50.5h29l-40 -198h-30q2 58 -11.5 70.5t-85.5 12.5h-99l-30 -167q-17 -87 3 -101q18 -15 111 -15q59 0 89 7t54 27q8 7 15.5 16t16 21.5
l14 20.5t15 23.5t13.5 21.5l29 -10q-52 -129 -71 -163h-500l6 28q66 4 83 17.5t28 73.5l77 409q11 61 -0.5 75.5t-78.5 18.5l10 28h467z" id="x1D438"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,104.728,12.138)"><path d="M275 270q0 -296 -211 -440l-19 23q75 62 116.5 174t41.5 243t-42 243t-116 173l19 24q211 -144 211 -440z" id="x29"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,110.61,12.138)"><path d="M95 130q31 0 61 -30t30 -78q0 -53 -38 -87.5t-93 -51.5l-11 29q77 31 77 85q0 26 -17.5 43t-44.5 24q-4 0 -8.5 6.5t-4.5 17.5q0 18 15 30t34 12z" id="x2C"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,117.307,12.138)"><path d="M1004 650l-6 -29q-54 -6 -71 -19.5t-51 -74.5l-271 -539h-33l-98 506h-3l-258 -506h-30l-78 532q-10 67 -21.5 80t-66.5 21l6 29h241l-8 -29l-26 -5q-34 -6 -41 -16t-3 -47l59 -425h4l251 510h31l102 -510h2q150 299 198 423q14 40 8.5 48.5t-47.5 16.5l-28 5l7 29h231z
" id="x1D44A"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,134.578,12.138)"><path d="M300 -147l-18 -23q-106 71 -159 185.5t-53 254.5v1q0 139 53 252.5t159 186.5l18 -24q-74 -62 -115.5 -173.5t-41.5 -242.5q0 -130 41.5 -242.5t115.5 -174.5z" id="x28"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,140.46,12.138)"><path d="M484 24v-24h-241v24q45 3 45 20q0 16 -33 64q-23 32 -42 63l-16 -20q-64 -76 -64 -103q0 -21 50 -24v-24h-169v24q27 1 49 19q20 16 64 74l43 56q8 9 11 14t11 14l-128 197q-15 23 -24 29.5t-28 9.5v24h250v-24q-47 -2 -47 -19q0 -22 58 -98q7 -8 13 -17l36 46
q38 50 38 64q0 11 -6.5 15.5t-24.5 6.5l-20 2v24h168v-24q-45 -8 -70 -39l-101 -126l148 -228q7 -12 30 -20z" id="x1D431"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.012,-0,0,-.012,148.975,16.212)"><path d="M412 140l28 -9q0 -2 -35 -131h-373v23q112 112 161 170q59 70 92 127t33 115q0 63 -31 98t-86 35q-75 0 -137 -93l-22 20l57 81q55 59 135 59q69 0 118.5 -46.5t49.5 -122.5q0 -62 -29.5 -114t-102.5 -130l-141 -149h186q42 0 58.5 10.5t38.5 56.5z" id="x32"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,155.312,12.138)"><path d="M95 130q31 0 61 -30t30 -78q0 -53 -38 -87.5t-93 -51.5l-11 29q77 31 77 85q0 26 -17.5 43t-44.5 24q-4 0 -8.5 6.5t-4.5 17.5q0 18 15 30t34 12z" id="x2C"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,162.01,12.138)"><path d="M434 650l-5 -28q-60 -8 -75 -20.5t-25 -69.5l-71 -395q-20 -107 -57.5 -168t-106.5 -94q-40 -18 -61 -20l-10 32q77 23 113 108q21 50 41 160l68 377q10 57 -1.5 69.5t-76.5 20.5l6 28h261z" id="x1D43D"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,169.778,12.138)"><path d="M300 -147l-18 -23q-106 71 -159 185.5t-53 254.5v1q0 139 53 252.5t159 186.5l18 -24q-74 -62 -115.5 -173.5t-41.5 -242.5q0 -130 41.5 -242.5t115.5 -174.5z" id="x28"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,175.66,12.138)"><path d="M1004 650l-6 -29q-54 -6 -71 -19.5t-51 -74.5l-271 -539h-33l-98 506h-3l-258 -506h-30l-78 532q-10 67 -21.5 80t-66.5 21l6 29h241l-8 -29l-26 -5q-34 -6 -41 -16t-3 -47l59 -425h4l251 510h31l102 -510h2q150 299 198 423q14 40 8.5 48.5t-47.5 16.5l-28 5l7 29h231z
" id="x1D44A"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,192.931,12.138)"><path d="M300 -147l-18 -23q-106 71 -159 185.5t-53 254.5v1q0 139 53 252.5t159 186.5l18 -24q-74 -62 -115.5 -173.5t-41.5 -242.5q0 -130 41.5 -242.5t115.5 -174.5z" id="x28"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,198.812,12.138)"><path d="M484 24v-24h-241v24q45 3 45 20q0 16 -33 64q-23 32 -42 63l-16 -20q-64 -76 -64 -103q0 -21 50 -24v-24h-169v24q27 1 49 19q20 16 64 74l43 56q8 9 11 14t11 14l-128 197q-15 23 -24 29.5t-28 9.5v24h250v-24q-47 -2 -47 -19q0 -22 58 -98q7 -8 13 -17l36 46
q38 50 38 64q0 11 -6.5 15.5t-24.5 6.5l-20 2v24h168v-24q-45 -8 -70 -39l-101 -126l148 -228q7 -12 30 -20z" id="x1D431"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.012,-0,0,-.012,207.325,16.212)"><path d="M285 378v-2q65 -13 102 -54.5t37 -97.5q0 -57 -30.5 -104.5t-74 -75t-85.5 -42t-72 -14.5q-31 0 -59.5 11t-40.5 23q-19 18 -16 36q1 16 23 33q13 10 24 0q58 -51 124 -51q55 0 88 40t33 112q0 64 -39 96.5t-88 32.5q-29 0 -64 -11l-6 29q77 25 118 57.5t41 84.5
q0 45 -26.5 69.5t-68.5 24.5q-67 0 -120 -79l-20 20l43 63q51 56 127 56h1q66 0 107 -37t41 -95q0 -42 -31 -71q-22 -23 -68 -54z" id="x33"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,213.65,12.138)"><path d="M95 130q31 0 61 -30t30 -78q0 -53 -38 -87.5t-93 -51.5l-11 29q77 31 77 85q0 26 -17.5 43t-44.5 24q-4 0 -8.5 6.5t-4.5 17.5q0 18 15 30t34 12z" id="x2C"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,220.348,12.138)"><path d="M609 650l-19 -162l-30 -2q2 69 -14 94q-9 18 -28.5 26t-74.5 8h-88q-30 0 -37 -6.5t-12 -36.5l-41 -212h103q48 0 69 5.5t32 19t26 50.5h29l-40 -198h-30q2 58 -11.5 70.5t-85.5 12.5h-99l-30 -167q-17 -87 3 -101q18 -15 111 -15q59 0 89 7t54 27q8 7 15.5 16t16 21.5
l14 20.5t15 23.5t13.5 21.5l29 -10q-52 -129 -71 -163h-500l6 28q66 4 83 17.5t28 73.5l77 409q11 61 -0.5 75.5t-78.5 18.5l10 28h467z" id="x1D438"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,231.091,12.138)"><path d="M275 270q0 -296 -211 -440l-19 23q75 62 116.5 174t41.5 243t-42 243t-116 173l19 24q211 -144 211 -440z" id="x29"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,236.972,12.138)"><path d="M95 130q31 0 61 -30t30 -78q0 -53 -38 -87.5t-93 -51.5l-11 29q77 31 77 85q0 26 -17.5 43t-44.5 24q-4 0 -8.5 6.5t-4.5 17.5q0 18 15 30t34 12z" id="x2C"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,243.687,12.138)"><path d="M609 650l-19 -162l-30 -2q2 69 -14 94q-9 18 -28.5 26t-74.5 8h-88q-30 0 -37 -6.5t-12 -36.5l-41 -212h103q48 0 69 5.5t32 19t26 50.5h29l-40 -198h-30q2 58 -11.5 70.5t-85.5 12.5h-99l-30 -167q-17 -87 3 -101q18 -15 111 -15q59 0 89 7t54 27q8 7 15.5 16t16 21.5
l14 20.5t15 23.5t13.5 21.5l29 -10q-52 -129 -71 -163h-500l6 28q66 4 83 17.5t28 73.5l77 409q11 61 -0.5 75.5t-78.5 18.5l10 28h467z" id="x1D438"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,254.43,12.138)"><path d="M275 270q0 -296 -211 -440l-19 23q75 62 116.5 174t41.5 243t-42 243t-116 173l19 24q211 -144 211 -440z" id="x29"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,260.312,12.138)"><path d="M275 270q0 -296 -211 -440l-19 23q75 62 116.5 174t41.5 243t-42 243t-116 173l19 24q211 -144 211 -440z" id="x29"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,266.193,12.138)"><path d="M275 270q0 -296 -211 -440l-19 23q75 62 116.5 174t41.5 243t-42 243t-116 173l19 24q211 -144 211 -440z" id="x29"></path></g>
</svg>.
The <svg height="12.1875" id="M25" style="vertical-align:-3.3907pt" version="1.1" viewbox="0 0 12.5 12.1875" width="12.5" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
<g transform="matrix(.017,-0,0,-.017,.062,7.9)"><path d="M484 24v-24h-241v24q45 3 45 20q0 16 -33 64q-23 32 -42 63l-16 -20q-64 -76 -64 -103q0 -21 50 -24v-24h-169v24q27 1 49 19q20 16 64 74l43 56q8 9 11 14t11 14l-128 197q-15 23 -24 29.5t-28 9.5v24h250v-24q-47 -2 -47 -19q0 -22 58 -98q7 -8 13 -17l36 46
q38 50 38 64q0 11 -6.5 15.5t-24.5 6.5l-20 2v24h168v-24q-45 -8 -70 -39l-101 -126l148 -228q7 -12 30 -20z" id="x1D431"></path></g>
<g transform="matrix(.012,-0,0,-.012,8.562,11.975)"><path d="M244 607q0 -25 -15.5 -43t-37.5 -18q-19 0 -32 13t-13 35q0 21 15 41t39 20q20 0 32 -14t12 -34zM222 91q-29 -33 -79 -68t-75 -35q-13 0 -19 7.5t-6 31t10 65.5l62 253q5 26 -1 26q-21 0 -72 -43l-13 24q43 40 91 68t71 28q30 0 10 -78l-71 -274q-8 -30 3 -30
q16 0 76 48z" id="x1D456"></path></g>
</svg> are coordinate vectors for the relative
positions of the structure elements.</table>

International Journal of Antennas and Propagation

fig1

Figure 1

Figure 1: A Comparison of Genetic Programming with Genetic Algorithms for Wire Antenna Design 