Identification of Control Parameters Using Taguchi Method for Hybrid Real-Binary Differential Evolution Algorithm and Its Applications in Electromagnetic Optimization

Table 8

Statistics of success rates and running times of 23 benchmarks performed by HDE, , and at the criteria of either the global best reaching or the NFFES reaching .

Functions			Success rates			Times (s)
			HDE (%)	(%)	(%)	HDE
	0	1.36E − 05	22	13	58	1216.49	1461.99	1297.74
	0	6.45E − 04	14	15	58	1482.24	1637.37	1215.51
	0	35.1	71	86	95	812.80	950.44	817.99
	0	0.337	14	2	14	1192.31	1257.03	1123.93
	0	41.5	36	95	87	1070.54	692.13	649.65
	0	0.372	21	96	66	1259.65	783.79	928.77
	0	0.0143	41	6	19	1658.40	1657.20	1519.22
	−5865.8	−5480	11	52	12	1140.49	1063.66	1175.29
	0	15.6	73	31	83	1116.22	1620.31	1254.30
	0	0.0106	24	78	42	1245.84	1200.16	1042.69
	0	0.0675	16	31	51	1184.87	1156.77	1048.72
	0	0.0962	51	95	70	844.21	586.37	772.00
	0	0.228	2	100	96	1182.40	635.94	552.72
	1	1	0	0	0	425.75	410.30	418.70
	0.0003	0.001	48	86	86	485.74	319.04	208.07
	−1.0316	−1.03	98	100	100	24.46	22.14	25.75
	0.398	0.398	87	100	100	70.90	40.47	28.25
	3	3	0	0	0	447.35	466.08	583.27
	−3.86	−3.86	85	100	97	162.40	48.94	106.44
	−3.32	−3.30	43	90	85	735.10	603.73	506.76
	−10.1532	−7.77	28	77	66	602.29	442.56	418.67
	−10.4028	−8.52	38	75	71	500.58	447.18	413.41
	−10.5363	−8.98	31	82	82	617.20	439.38	373.11