Identification of Control Parameters Using Taguchi Method for Hybrid Real-Binary Differential Evolution Algorithm and Its Applications in Electromagnetic Optimization

Table 9

The statistics of case 1 and case 2 for PMA designs.

Algorithms	Case 1 (0.2–2) GHz				Case 2 (2–8) GHz
	Max	Min	Avr	Std	Max	Min	Avr	Std
HPSO [4]	−16.74	−28.38	−21.42	4.09	−17.5	−24.1	−21.92	1.77
IHPSO [6]	−17.18	−28.38	−23.74	4.93	−22.28	−25.34	−23.57	0.73
HDE [5]	−17.20	−28.38	−24.16	3.47	−20.94	−25.78	−23.73	1.06
	−16.99	−28.04	−24.80	2.70	−22.05	−25.35	−23.37	0.73
	−21.39	−28.37	−25.43	2.61	−22.36	−25.46	−23.92	0.86