Review Article

Obesity Disease and Surgery

Table 4


ProcedureAdvantagesDisadvantages

Vertical banded gastroplasty(i) No intestinal anastomosis(i) Foreign body
(ii) No malabsorption(ii) High long-term failure rate

Adjustable gastric banding(i) Technically simple(i) Foreign body
(ii) Low morbidity(ii) 15–30% failure rate
(iii) Reversible(iii) May promote maladaptive eating behaviour
(iv) No intestinal anastomosis
(v) No malabsorption

Sleeve gastrectomy(i) Technically simple(i) May require second-stage procedure
(ii) Low morbidity(ii) Unknown long-term results

Gastric bypass(i) Sustained weight loss(i) Intestinal anastamoses
(ii) Dumping in sweet eaters(ii) Loss of access to gastric remnant
(iii) Resolution of gastroesophageal
reflux disease
(iii) Mild risk for vitamin deficiencies
(iv) Risk of marginal ulceration

Biliopancreatic diversion-duodenal switch(i) Excellent sustained weight loss(i) Technically demanding
(ii) Larger portion size(ii) Frequent bowel movement and flatulence
(iii) Excellent malabsorption(iii) Increased risk of vitamin and protein malnutrition