Review Article

Hypertensive Response to Exercise in Athletes: Unremarkable Finding or Relevant Marker for Future Cardiovascular Complications?

Table 2

Study characteristics of included studies with athletes.

Author (year)Study size (n)Definition for HREAge (years)Gender (% male)Exercise testing protocolType of athleteStudy designSummary of findings

Currie et al. [35]22SBP 190–210 mmHg55.5 ± 573Graded exercise testEndurance athletesCross-sectionalNo cardiovascular dysfunction. Similar parameters of sympathetic reactivity, LV structure and function and central arterial stiffness were observed in athletes with and without HRE
Turmel et al. [36]44SBP ≥220 mmHg, DBP ≥110 mmHg2063.2Progressive maximal aerobic exercise test (RAMP)Endurance athletesCross-sectionalAthletes with HRE had a higher BP during exercise at every intensity and higher SBP during 24 h ABPM. Lower apo-A1 serum levels in athletes with HRE imply a higher risk for cardiovascular disease
Caselli et al. [13]1876SBP ≥220 mmHg for male, 200 mmHg for female, DBP ≥85 mmHg for male, ≥80 mmHg for female25 ± 664Symptom-limited bicycle testing; increase in workload of 0.5 W/kg every 2 minOlympic athletes classified in 4 subgroups; skill, power, mixed, enduranceCross-sectional7.5% had HRE. These athletes had larger BMI and were more commonly engaged in endurance and mixed sports
Leischik et al. [37]51No definition37100Progressive maximal aerobic exercise test (RAMP)TriathletesCross-sectionalAthletes with HRE show higher LV mass than athletes without HRE
Malek et al. [38]30SBP ≥210 mmHg DBP ≥90 mmHg or increase of DBP more than 10 mmHg above resting values40.9 ± 6.6100Exercise test on treadmillUltra-marathon runnersCross-sectionalAthletes with high-normal BP showed higher interventricular septal thickness and higher left and right ventricular mass index. Combined with HRE these findings were more pronounced. Athletes with isolated HRE did not show LV hypertrophy
Tahir et al. [39]83SBP ≥214 mmHg43 ± 1065Progressive maximal aerobic exercise test (RAMP); increase in workload of 20–40 W/minTriathletesCross-sectionalIn male triathletes, higher maximal SBP values during exercise and longer race distances in swimming and cycling were independent predictors for focal myocardial fibrosis
Tahir et al. [40]30No definition45 ± 10100Post-race examinationsTriathletesCross-sectionalTriathletes with myocardial fibrosis had elevated post-race NT-proBNP levels, higher peak systolic HRE and lower post-race LA ejection fraction
Bauer et al. [41]142No definition26 ± 5100Progressive maximal aerobic cycling ergometer test; increase in workload of 50 W every 2 minHandball and ice hockey playersCross-sectionalAthletes with the lowest SBP/MET slope had the lowest maximum SBP but achieved the highest absolute and relative workload
Caselli et al. [14]141SBP ≥220 mmHg for male, 200 mmHg for female, DBP ≥85 mmHg for male, ≥80 mmHg for female26 ± 666Symptom-limited bicycle testing; increase in workload of 0.5 W/kg every 2 minEndurance, power and mixed disciplinesProspective (6.5 ± 2.8)Athletes with HRE had 3.6 times higher risk of developing hypertension compared to those with normal BP response to exercise. No cardiac remodeling during follow up was found
Kim et al. [42]17SBP ≥210 mmHg51.7 ± 7.7100Bruce protocolAmateur marathon runnersCase-controlMarathon runners with HRE showed a greater LVMI and had more LV diastolic dysfunction than hypertensive sedentary subjects

N = 2436, age = 38.95, IQR = 19, (% male) = 86.5, IQR 35. Abbreviations: HRE, hypertensive response to exercise; LVMI, left ventricular mass index; CRP, C reactive protein; BMI, body mass index; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; ABPM, ambulatory blood pressure monitoring; BP, blood pressure; MH, masked hypertension; RAAS, renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system; SBP, systolic blood pressure; LV, left ventricular; NO, nitrogen monoxide; CV, cardiovascular; CVD, cardiovascular disease; GMP, guanosine monophosphate; ADMA, asymmetric dimethylarginine.