Research Article

Cost-Utility Analysis of Mycophenolate Mofetil versus Azathioprine Based Regimens for Maintenance Therapy of Proliferative Lupus Nephritis

Table 3

(a) Costs, effectiveness, and incremental cost effectiveness ratios (ICER) of the base-case and individual clinical trials in three-year model. (b) Sensitivity analysis of three-year model using Cochrane data.
(a)

ScenariosTotal cost ($)Total effectiveness (QALY)Incremental costs ($)Incremental effectiveness (QALY)ICER ($/QALY)

Cochrane (base-case)
 AZA54,249.981.6367
 MMF71,861.211.643417,611.230.00672,630,591.76
Subgroups
 ALMS
  AZA55,959.121.6125
  MMF72,619.051.636316,659.920.0238700,001.12
 MAINTAIN
  AZA54,527.621.6318
  MMF72,511.651.614817,984.04−0.0170Dominated

QALY: quality-adjusted life-years; AZA: azathioprine; MMF: mycophenolate mofetil.
(b)

ScenariosICER MMF versus AZA (US$)

Base-case2,630,591.76
Excludes indirect costs in both strategies2,529,609.93
Utility
Remission = 0.8 (versus base-case 0.7)1,476,631.93
Relapse requiring MMF = 0.5 (versus base-case 0.6)1,654,369.09
Utility of relapse requiring CYC = utility of relapse requiring MMF rescue2,555,137.00
Conditions biased against AZA-based strategy
Indirect costs × 6 months during remission ($10,041.49) [higher indirect costs for AZA group]2,410,632.95
Indirect costs × 6 months during remission ($10,041.49) + utility of remission state (0.8) [higher indirect costs for AZA group + higher utility during remission]1,380,997.67
Indirect costs × 6 months during remission ($10,041.49) + utility of remission state (0.8) + drug costs of AZA × 6 months ($2626) [higher indirect costs for AZA group + higher utility during remission + higher drug costs of AZA]709,870.18
Revised assumptions
AZA group receives 3 gm/day of MMF as rescue (base-case 2 gm/day MMF)1,900,694.28
Patients in the AZA group who remit on CYC rescue therapy are treated with AZA maintenance therapy (base-case MMF 2 gm/day)2,273,422.51

ICER: incremental cost effectiveness ratio; AZA: azathioprine; MMF: mycophenolate mofetil.