A Cooperative Coevolutionary Cuckoo Search Algorithm for Optimization Problem

Table 4

The comparison between OEA, SMES, and CCCS.

𝑓	𝑓min	Method	Best FV	Mean FV	St. dev	Worst FV
𝐺01	−15	CCCS	−15	−15	0	−15
		OEA CHp	−15	−15	0	−15
		OEA CHc	−15	−14.78	7.637𝑒−1	−12
		SMES	−15.000	−15.000	0	−15.000
𝐺02	−0.803619	CCCS	−0.7947	−0.7826	0.0093	−0.7694
		OEA CHp	−0.803605	−0.782518	1.483𝑒−2	−0.746283
		OEA CHc	−0.803589	−0.782676	1.512𝑒−2	−0.743149
		SMES	−0.803601	−0.795238	1.67𝑒−2	−0.751322
𝐺03	−1	CCCS	−1.000	−1.000	0	−1.000
		OEA CHp	−1.000	−1.000	8.470𝑒−6	−1.000
		OEA CHc	−1.000	−1.000	1.131𝑒−5	−1.000
		SMES	−1.000	−1.000	2.09𝑒−4	−1.000
𝐺04	−30665.539	CCCS	−3.0665539e + 004	−3.0665539e + 004	3.8348e − 012	−3.0665539e + 004
		OEA CHp	−30665.539	−30665.539	1.735𝑒−11	−30665.539
		OEA CHc	−30665.539	−30665.539	1.837𝑒−11	−30665.539
		SMES	−30665.539	−30665.539	0	−30665.539
𝐺05	5126.498	CCCS	5.1264981e + 003	5.1264981e + 003	9.5869e − 013	5.1264981e + 003
		OEA CHp	5126.497	5127.048	7.071𝑒−1	5130.051
		OEA CHc	5126.532	5315.975	145.473	5900.26
		SMES	5126.599	5174.492	50.06	5304.167
𝐺06	−6961.814	CCCS	−6.9618139e + 003	−6.9618139e + 003	9.5869e − 013	−6.9618139e + 003
		OEA CHp	−6961.814	−6961.814	5.512𝑒−12	−6961.814
		OEA CHc	−6961.814	−6961.814	5.512𝑒−12	−6961.814
		SMES	−6961.814	−6861.284	1.85	−6952.482
𝐺07	24.306	CCCS	2.4306209e + 001	2.4306209e + 001	4.2164e − 007	2.4306209e + 001
		OEA CHp	24.308	24.373	7.615𝑒−2	24.655
		OEA CHc	24.307	24.392	1.178𝑒−1	24.973
		SMES	24.327	24.475	1.32𝑒−1	24.843
𝐺08	−0.095825	CCCS	−9.5825041e − 002	−9.5825041e − 002	0	−9.5825041e − 002
		OEA CHp	−0.095825	−0.095825	0	−0.095825
		OEA CHc	−0.095825	−0.095825	0	−0.095825
		SMES	−0.095825	−0.095825	0	−0.095825
𝐺09	680.630	CCCS	6.8063006e + 002	6.8063006e + 002	1.1984e − 013	6.8063006e + 002
		OEA CHp	680.630	680.632	1.718𝑒−3	680.638
		OEA CHc	680.630	680.632	2.163𝑒−3	680.641
		SMES	680.632	680.643	1.55𝑒−2	680.719
𝐺10	7049.331	CCCS	7.0492e + 003	7.0492e + 003	4.7796e − 004	7.0492e + 003
		OEA CHp	7052.236	7219.011	60.737	7326.032
		OEA CHc	7100.030	7231.357	86.409	7469.047
		SMES	7051.903	7253.603	136.02	7638.366
𝐺11	0.750	CCCS	0.7500	0.7500	0	0.7500
		OEA CHp	0.750	0.750	5.993𝑒−5	0.750
		OEA CHc	0.750	0.750	1.881𝑒−7	0.750
		SMES	0.75	0.75	1.52𝑒−4	0.75