Research Article

Composition Characterization of Fatty Acid Zinc Salts by Chromatographic and NMR Spectroscopic Analyses on Their Fatty Acid Methyl Esters

Table 1

Simplified comparison of typical preparation methods for fatty acid methyl esters from various lipids.

Methods/reagentOptimized or recommended conditionsaAnalytesbRef./year

(A) Acid-catalyzed esterification/transesterification
Anhydrous methanolic hydrogen chlorideReflux, 2 h or 50°C, overnight (5% HCl)Other than FFA[11] 1993
50°C, 30 min (5% HCl)FFA
Conc. HCl/methanol/toluene45°C, 8 h (1.2% HCl)cTG, PhL[12] 2010
45°C, 14 h (0.6% HCl)TG, PhL
45°C, 16 h (1.2% HCl)SE
45°C, 20 min (0.5% HCl)FFA
45°C, 60 min (0.2% HCl)FFA
100°C, 30 min (1.2% HCl)TG, PhL
100°C, 90 min (1.2% HCl)SE
100°C, 5 min (0.2% HCl)FFA

(B) Esterification/transesterification by BF3-methanol or modified BF3-methanol
BF3-methanol100°C, 2 min (14% BF3)FFA[13] 1964
BF3-methanol/onert solvent100°C, 30 min (25% BF3)d 100°C, 45 min (35% BF3)dTG SE
NaOH saponification/methanolic BF3100°C, 5 min (0.5 N NaOH)/100°C, 2 min (12.5% BF3)Cottonseed oil[14] 1966
100°C, 5 min (0.5 N NaOH)/100°C, 30 min (14% BF3)Lipids in foods[15] 2017 KFDA
KOH saponification/acidification/methanolic BF370°C, 1 h (0.5 M KOH)/2 M HCl/RT, 20 min (15% BF3)Lipid mixture[16] 1996
Hydrolysis by HCl/methanolic BF380°C, 40 min (8.3 M HCl)/100°C, 45 min (7% BF3)TG, FFA in foods[17] 2002 AOAC

C. Alkali-catalyzed transesterification
Anhydrous sodium or potassium methoxide50°C, 10 min (0.5 to 2 M CH3ONa, 100-fold excess)TG[11] 1993
50°C, 5 minPhL
50°C, 1 hSE
Methanolic NaOH or KOHRT, 2 min (2 M KOH)eTG[16] 1996
37°C, 1 min (2 M KOH)eTG
RT, 15 h (0.1 M KOH)eTG
37°C, 1 h (0.5 M NaOH)c,f 37°C, 40 min (0.5 M NaOH)c,fSE wax[18] 2003

aYield of FAME: 97%∼100%. bAnalytes are lipids: TG, triglyceride; FFA, free fatty acid; SE, sterol ester, cholesteryl ester; PhL, phospholipids. cConcentration in final volume. d, e, fInert solvent is added: d, benzene; e, hexane; f, methyl propionate.