Research Article

Decision-Support Framework for Selecting the Optimal Road Toll Collection System

Table 11

Stability intervals matrix for criteria weight regarding the complete ranking and the first place.

CriteriaComplete ranking remains unchanged (%)First place remains unchanged (%)

Interoperability3.18–6.033.18–10.57
Efficiency0.00–7.360.00–100.00
Flexibility2.86–8.322.25–18.44
Reliability/accuracy1.63–6.680.00–8.84
Enforcement2.86–7.260.00–13.96
Level of service0.00–7.530.00–100.00
Traffic safety3.97–6.302.89–15.24
Number of stops0.00–7.360.00–100.00
An increase in travel time0.00–15.100.00–100.00
Average cost for user4.39–8.020.00–8.02
Ratio of revenues/costs5.48–23.901.39–100.00
Capex5.65–7.732.98–7.73
Opex4.30–10.100.00–27.62
Visual impact of defacing ambient environment1.25–6.480.00–100.00
Air pollution0.00–5.390.00–100.00
Noise0.00–14.180.00–100.00
Fair payment0.00–10.560.00–100.00
Easy to use0.00–11.970.00–100.00
Aesthetic effect on the vehicle2.10–7.200.00–12.06
Possibility of theft and fraud0.00–6.710.00–17.80