| | | | | Sampling approach | MIP-DF1 | MIP-DF2 | Sampling approach | MIP-DF1 | MIP-DF2 | Sampling approach | MIP-DF1 | MIP-DF2 | CT | Obj | Sel (%) | Sel (%) | Sel (%) | CT | Obj | Sel (%) | Sel (%) | Sel (%) | CT | Obj | Sel (%) | Sel (%) | Sel (%) |
| 1 | (2,6) | 2.7 | 90 | 72.94 | 99.67 | 90.01 | 2.7 | 98 | 77.70 | 99.79 | 90.13 | 2.4 | 103 | 92.73 | 99.99 | 94.68 | 2 | (4,12) | 4.6 | 170 | 79.61 | 99.21 | 91.17 | 5.1 | 183 | 83.05 | 99.46 | 91.28 | 4.9 | 201 | 93.92 | 99.98 | 95.46 | 3 | (6,18) | 6.8 | 258 | 75.78 | 99.38 | 89.11 | 7.4 | 280 | 80.28 | 99.68 | 90.04 | 6.9 | 307 | 91.82 | 99.99 | 96.58 | 4 | (8,24) | 9.3 | 315 | 80.01 | 99.28 | 91.96 | 10.2 | 338 | 84.38 | 99.67 | 91.72 | 9.2 | 368 | 94.68 | 99.99 | 96.13 | 5 | (10,30) | 12.0 | 413 | 80.41 | 99.39 | 94.49 | 13.3 | 443 | 84.47 | 99.76 | 92.72 | 12.1 | 479 | 95.44 | 99.99 | 97.52 | 6 | (12,36) | 15.5 | 476 | 80.84 | 98.77 | 95.54 | 16.7 | 508 | 88.63 | 99.91 | 95.69 | 15.9 | 536 | 94.56 | 99.99 | 97.34 | 7 | (14,42) | 19.5 | 573 | 78.76 | 98.92 | 96.63 | 21.3 | 609 | 91.24 | 99.98 | 97.29 | 20.5 | 643 | 93.14 | 100.00 | 97.68 | 8 | (16,48) | 23.2 | 687 | 79.64 | 99.97 | 97.88 | 26.7 | 724 | 85.23 | 99.88 | 96.87 | 23.8 | 772 | 94.22 | 99.98 | 96.89 | 9 | (18,54) | 29.3 | 692 | 82.67 | 98.93 | 98.09 | 32.7 | 730 | 83.86 | 99.99 | 97.50 | 29.8 | 757 | 92.28 | 99.99 | 97.55 | 10 | (20,60) | 35.6 | 796 | 79.46 | 98.99 | 98.01 | 39.9 | 840 | 82.99 | 99.76 | 96.86 | 36.0 | 885 | 96.68 | 99.99 | 97.05 | 11 | (22,66) | 42.3 | 829 | 82.01 | 98.95 | 97.56 | 48.9 | 877 | 83.78 | 99.87 | 97.88 | 44.8 | 927 | 94.76 | 99.99 | 98.12 | 12 | (24,72) | 51.2 | 1023 | 83.38 | 99.13 | 98.53 | 55.4 | 1085 | 85.01 | 99.99 | 98.81 | 51.4 | 1148 | 93.98 | 99.99 | 98.88 | 13 | (26,78) | 59.2 | 1045 | 84.16 | 99.07 | 98.73 | 68.7 | 1088 | 79.98 | 99.96 | 98.02 | 60.7 | 1152 | 95.04 | 99.99 | 98.21 | 14 | (28,84) | 72.3 | 1099 | 79.46 | 99.15 | 97.88 | 83.8 | 1166 | 80.56 | 99.92 | 98.29 | 77.6 | 1230 | 95.46 | 99.99 | 98.39 | 15 | (30,90) | 85.5 | 1089 | 79.15 | 99.64 | 97.03 | 94.2 | 1156 | 84.32 | 99.84 | 97.78 | 90.3 | 1225 | 92.23 | 99.98 | 97.85 | 16 | (32,96) | 100.9 | 1158 | 80.24 | 98.97 | 97.69 | 116.3 | 1231 | 85.00 | 99.96 | 98.24 | 104.5 | 1222 | 91.99 | 99.99 | 98.35 | 17 | (34,102) | 116.5 | 1299 | 80.34 | 99.19 | 97.79 | 128.5 | 1375 | 84.95 | 99.37 | 98.08 | 119.0 | 1457 | 92.58 | 100.00 | 98.46 | 18 | (36,108) | 125.4 | 1411 | 81.76 | 99.43 | 98.85 | 147.9 | 1492 | 85.61 | 99.68 | 98.68 | 134.5 | 1579 | 92.86 | 99.99 | 98.75 | 19 | (38,114) | 150.4 | 1506 | 79.70 | 99.23 | 98.42 | 165.1 | 1594 | 81.67 | 99.72 | 98.46 | 156.4 | 1694 | 93.76 | 99.99 | 97.86 | 20 | (40,120) | 170.6 | 1635 | 78.19 | 99.16 | 97.83 | 185.4 | 1734 | 86.07 | 99.68 | 97.76 | 177.8 | 1825 | 92.85 | 99.04 | 97.18 | 21 | (42,126) | 205.4 | 1622 | 83.54 | 99.18 | 98.34 | 235.7 | 1720 | 82.97 | 99.78 | 98.33 | 222.6 | 1856 | 95.01 | 99.99 | 98.34 | 22 | (44,132) | 240.0 | 1736 | 84.94 | 99.22 | 98.46 | 285.2 | 1844 | 82.69 | 99.99 | 98.16 | 268.0 | 1946 | 94.86 | 99.99 | 98.20 | 23 | (46,138) | 265.1 | 1934 | 81.41 | 99.53 | 97.93 | 315.9 | 2049 | 84.92 | 99.69 | 97.99 | 307.2 | 2172 | 93.58 | 100.00 | 98.13 | 24 | (48,144) | 300.4 | 1961 | 82.26 | 99.47 | 96.81 | 352.2 | 2086 | 85.13 | 99.98 | 97.06 | 310.2 | 2209 | 94.88 | 99.99 | 97.24 | 25 | (50,150) | 330.8 | 1924 | 81.11 | 99.65 | 97.46 | 389.8 | 2038 | 82.64 | 99.99 | 97.88 | 363.9 | 2161 | 95.46 | 99.99 | 98.13 | 26 | (52,156) | 366.9 | 1911 | 80.96 | 99.39 | 98.55 | 430.5 | 2027 | 87.22 | 99.67 | 98.74 | 445.3 | 2142 | 91.85 | 99.99 | 98.76 | 27 | (54,162) | 441.8 | 2095 | 83.87 | 99.27 | 97.54 | 477.1 | 2219 | 83.41 | 99.89 | 97.49 | 480.6 | 2353 | 92.89 | 99.99 | 97.55 | 28 | (56,168) | 536.7 | 2113 | 84.58 | 99.68 | 98.48 | 535.6 | 2237 | 84.52 | 99.78 | 98.55 | 522.1 | 2369 | 92.28 | 100.00 | 98.68 | 29 | (58,174) | 621.7 | 2186 | 79.98 | 99.89 | 96.94 | 594.2 | 2315 | 83.16 | 99.96 | 96.99 | 585.3 | 2371 | 91.67 | 99.99 | 97.05 | 30 | (60,180) | 726.3 | 2382 | 83.21 | 99.91 | 98.37 | 652.7 | 2543 | 83.59 | 99.98 | 98.86 | 621.4 | 2678 | 93.69 | 99.97 | 98.86 | 31 | (62,186) | 821.4 | 2346 | 84.04 | 99.36 | 98.88 | 781.3 | 2430 | 83.21 | 99.99 | 98.46 | 687.6 | 2560 | 93.58 | 99.99 | 98.47 | 32 | (64,192) | 886.3 | 2518 | 83.78 | 99.38 | 98.07 | 810.6 | 2677 | 83.56 | 99.99 | 98.33 | 787.7 | 2822 | 94.08 | 100.00 | 98.35 | 33 | (66,198) | 998.5 | 2532 | 84.06 | 99.17 | 97.09 | 968.4 | 2689 | 84.97 | 99.96 | 97.46 | 808.8 | 2838 | 95.07 | 99.99 | 97.49 | 34 | (68,204) | 1126.4 | 2534 | 85.43 | 99.08 | 98.97 | 1098.6 | 2685 | 88.09 | 99.96 | 97.82 | 846.9 | 2843 | 88.44 | 99.98 | 97.80 | 35 | (70,210) | 1203.5 | 2715 | 82.58 | 99.37 | 97.99 | 1209.8 | 2886 | 85.69 | 99.91 | 98.09 | 994.6 | 3041 | 94.59 | 99.99 | 98.13 | 36 | (72,216) | 1280.3 | 2825 | 81.04 | 99.29 | 98.27 | 1307.6 | 3010 | 86.51 | 99.94 | 98.34 | 1101.3 | 3170 | 94.68 | 99.99 | 98.65 | 37 | (74,222) | 1302.1 | 2830 | 82.28 | 99.49 | 98.26 | 1326.1 | 3009 | 83.76 | 99.99 | 98.26 | 1201.4 | 3172 | 93.46 | 99.99 | 98.88 | 38 | (76,228) | 1386.2 | 2843 | 81.52 | 99.33 | 98.07 | 1399.5 | 3028 | 87.60 | 99.98 | 98.41 | 1213.3 | 3187 | 97.06 | 99.99 | 98.76 | 39 | (78,234) | 1538.7 | 2953 | 83.12 | 99.64 | 97.99 | 1482.7 | 3133 | 90.01 | 99.95 | 97.83 | 1338.1 | 3304 | 89.13 | 99.99 | 97.99 | 40 | (80,240) | 1697.4 | 2975 | 85.10 | 99.85 | 97.67 | 1525.6 | 3249 | 82.17 | 99.93 | 97.81 | 1586.7 | 3347 | 91.11 | 99.99 | 97.91 |
| Average | 435.2 | 1587.5 | 81.43 | 99.34 | 97.08 | 436.2 | 1685.6 | 84.37 | 99.85 | 97.07 | 396.8 | 1776.3 | 93.56 | 99.97 | 97.81 |
|
|