A Comparative Evaluation of Public Road Transportation Systems in India Using Multicriteria Decision-Making Techniques

Table 11

Malmquist productivity change index of DMUs.

DMU	Accident	Traffic revenue	Expenses	Vehicle operations	Manpower	Maintenance	M0
Ahmedabad MTC	1.028	1.031	3.817	0.987	1.022	1.319	1.774
Andhra Pradesh SRTC	0.849	0.972	2.624	0.92	0.864	0.795	1.345
Andaman & Nicobar ST	0.916	0.834	2.984	0.938	0.859	0.981	1.430
Assam STC	0.755	1.132	2.615	1.017	0.826	0.715	1.375
BEST Undertaking	0.83	0.992	2.797	0.947	0.875	0.805	1.400
Bangalore Metropolitan TC	0.792	1.063	2.937	1.038	0.691	0.76	1.430
Bihar SRTC	0.854	0.947	2.834	1.033	1.246	0.825	1.471
Calcutta STC	0.903	0.895	2.943	0.761	0.776	0.941	1.393
Chandigarh TU	0.86	1.061	2.901	1.048	1.21	0.743	1.505
Delhi TC	0.841	0.958	2.874	0.94	0.96	0.845	1.428
Gujarat SRTC	0.83	0.957	2.681	0.974	0.939	0.821	1.376
Haryana ST	0.769	1.029	2.374	1.003	0.978	0.732	1.310
J&K SRTC	0.761	0.94	2.819	0.897	0.796	0.942	1.382
Kadamba TC Ltd.	0.834	1.021	2.797	0.953	1.03	0.816	1.433
Karnataka SRTC	0.786	0.926	2.469	0.99	0.87	0.76	1.294
Kerala SRTC	0.897	1.001	2.827	0.924	0.942	0.954	1.439
Maharashtra SRTC(P)	0.84	0.972	2.845	0.965	0.907	0.859	1.421
Meghalaya STC	0.821	1.164	2.733	1.162	1.142	0.758	1.492
Metro TC (Chennai) Ltd.	0.823	0.948	2.667	0.991	0.905	0.802	1.365
Mizoram ST	0.737	0.866	2.885	0.83	0.587	0.737	1.314
Nagaland ST	0.835	0.951	2.675	1.217	1.005	0.676	1.401
Navi Mumbai MT	0.894	1.056	2.906	0.929	0.962	0.945	1.476
North Bengal STC	0.831	1.206	2.839	1.037	1.341	0.835	1.553
North Eastern Karnataka RT	0.825	0.952	2.704	0.997	0.819	0.833	1.366
North Western Karnataka RT	0.797	0.957	2.541	0.999	0.921	0.776	1.333
Odisha SRTC	0.823	1.028	2.559	1.03	1.079	0.801	1.389
Pune Mahamandal	0.835	1.06	2.803	0.963	0.93	0.88	1.438
PUNBUS	0.869	0.959	2.746	1.031	0.924	0.895	1.410
State Transport Punjab	0.86	0.976	2.819	0.927	1.133	0.83	1.444
Rajasthan SRTC	0.764	0.991	2.445	0.974	0.93	0.748	1.309
Sikkim NT	0.814	1.108	2.742	0.843	0.8	1.061	1.416
South Bengal STC	0.834	1.028	2.799	1.118	1.19	0.846	1.486
State Exp.TC TN Ltd.	0.891	0.982	2.9	0.941	1.044	0.894	1.464
Telangana SRTC	0.836	0.901	2.687	0.936	0.839	0.794	1.340
Thane MT	0.788	0.901	2.611	0.925	0.864	0.73	1.312
TN STC (Coimbatore) Ltd.	0.834	0.971	2.747	0.971	0.934	0.854	1.399
TN STC (Kumbakonam) Ltd.	0.794	0.9	2.777	0.916	0.886	0.82	1.367
TN STC (Madurai) Ltd.	0.828	0.961	2.775	0.956	0.901	0.859	1.397
TN STC (Salem) Ltd.	0.827	0.739	2.751	0.95	0.55	0.867	1.279
TN STC (Villupuram) Ltd.	0.795	0.935	2.606	0.938	0.923	0.812	1.340
Tripura RTC	1.022	0.732	3.689	0.711	2.217	1.029	1.778
Uttar Pradesh SRTC (P)	0.793	0.895	2.459	0.962	0.998	0.759	1.300
Average (M0)	0.836	0.973	2.785	0.966	0.967	0.844	1.413