Two-Phase Optimization Models for Liner Shipping Network Based on Hub Ports Cooperation: From the Perspective of Supply-Side Reform in China

Table 3

The results of LSN in NO phase (G³).

G^3(%)	o ⟶ d	ΔQod (%)	Δeod (%)	G^3 (%)	o ⟶ d	ΔQod (%)	Δeod (%)	G^3 (%)	o ⟶ d	ΔQod (%)	Δeod (%)
100	1 ⟶ 9	1	−14	91.91	7 ⟶ 11	4	−7	83.23	4 ⟶ 12	9	−5
100	4 ⟶ 10	2	−8	91.82	12 ⟶ 8	−5	−8	83.07	11 ⟶ 2	−8	−17
100	4 ⟶ 14	8	−6	91.68	3 ⟶ 14	1	−12	82.68	12 ⟶ 2	−10	−2
100	5 ⟶ 9	6	−14	91.56	1 ⟶ 12	−23	−7	82.56	3 ⟶ 11	8	−20
100	5 ⟶ 11	9	−9	91.34	7 ⟶ 10	−5	−2	82.29	13 ⟶ 1	−10	−10
100	6 ⟶ 9	5	−10	91.02	13 ⟶ 5	10	−16	81.73	6 ⟶ 12	8	−9
100	7 ⟶ 12	−7	−7	90.59	2 ⟶ 10	−10	−8	81.10	13 ⟶ 2	−10	−20
100	8 ⟶ 12	−2	−10	90.51	10 ⟶ 4	6	−10	79.80	6 ⟶ 10	−2	−7
100	9 ⟶ 1	10	−16	90.26	12 ⟶ 4	2	−3	79.67	14 ⟶ 4	−1	−13
100	9 ⟶ 3	10	−6	90.01	11 ⟶ 8	−9	−19	79.13	9 ⟶ 8	−8	−4
100	9 ⟶ 5	9	−8	89.53	12 ⟶ 6	−1	−7	77.06	13 ⟶ 7	6	−12
100	9 ⟶ 6	2	−7	89.44	4 ⟶ 11	−1	−13	77.02	12 ⟶ 1	−7	−4
100	11 ⟶ 4	1	−11	89.03	5 ⟶ 14	−9	−3	76.62	14 ⟶ 3	−5	−10
100	12 ⟶ 5	6	−12	88.89	8 ⟶ 14	9	−11	76.57	7 ⟶ 9	−5	−2
100	12 ⟶ 7	9	−5	88.55	8 ⟶ 13	1	−8	75.78	10 ⟶ 1	−9	−17
100	13 ⟶ 4	7	−4	88.45	6 ⟶ 14	−6	−4	75.34	10 ⟶ 2	−4	−6
100	13 ⟶ 6	10	−11	88.39	6 ⟶ 13	−7	−2	74.71	1 ⟶ 11	−5	−17
100	14 ⟶ 7	−8	−9	87.92	3 ⟶ 13	0	−18	73.18	2 ⟶ 14	2	−8
99.43	4 ⟶ 9	3	−11	87.89	7 ⟶ 14	4	−2	72.72	11 ⟶ 5	−8	−11
99.39	11 ⟶ 6	2	−6	87.76	11 ⟶ 3	9	−5	72.71	1 ⟶ 13	−7	−7
99.33	6 ⟶ 11	4	−7	86.89	10 ⟶ 3	10	−20	72.46	14 ⟶ 6	−10	−20
97.80	9 ⟶ 7	10	−7	86.73	13 ⟶ 3	−5	−3	72.01	1 ⟶ 14	0	−9
95.84	5 ⟶ 13	10	−2	86.49	2 ⟶ 11	10	−11	69.76	11 ⟶ 1	−2	−6
95.58	8 ⟶ 10	6	−3	86.10	5 ⟶ 12	−2	−20	69.41	1 ⟶ 10	2	−10
95.30	8 ⟶ 11	5	−13	85.77	5 ⟶ 10	6	−6	66.96	10 ⟶ 7	−8	−7
94.51	8 ⟶ 9	−9	−9	85.57	3 ⟶ 9	7	−13	62.50	9 ⟶ 4	−6	−12
94.30	12 ⟶ 3	9	−7	85.54	3 ⟶ 10	−3	−20	52.64	14 ⟶ 8	−4	−5
93.42	4 ⟶ 13	9	−20	84.85	10 ⟶ 5	1	−6	42.80	9 ⟶ 2	−12	−20
93.28	3 ⟶ 12	10	−11	84.53	2 ⟶ 12	−10	−8	41.11	10 ⟶ 6	−8	−17
92.89	2 ⟶ 9	−8	−10	84.24	2 ⟶ 13	−1	−14	24.96	11 ⟶ 7	−5	−11
92.87	13 ⟶ 8	−1	−9	84.21	7 ⟶ 13	5	−6	16.54	14 ⟶ 5	−10	−13
92.54	14 ⟶ 1	2	−5	83.63	14 ⟶ 2	1	−12	2.72	10 ⟶ 8	−7	−11