Research Article

Sustainability Assessment of Chemical Processes: Evaluation of Three Synthesis Routes of DMC

Table 9

Summary of sustainability assessment, benefits, and challenges to sustainability.

Benefits driving sustainabilityChallenges to sustainability

Route A
(i) CO2 used as feedstock 
(ii) High volume of academic papers  
(iii) Lowest total cost per produced DMC 
(iv) Safest chemicals
(i) Low yield, low conversion 
(ii) Methylformate as waste 
(iii) High energy consumption 
(iv) High pressure process

Route B
(i) CO2 is a feedstock in the first step 
(ii) Valuable by-product  
(iii) Energy win 
(iv) Intensified academic research 
(v) Consuming all CO2
(i) Oil refinery product used as feedstock  
(ii) Low yield 
(iii) Propylene oxide use is an inherent risk  
(iv) Highest total cost per produced DMC 
(v) High process temperature and pressure

Route C
(i) Highest yield  
(ii) No waste
(i) Use of CO as reactant is an inherent risk 
(ii) High feedstock and process costs
(iii) High temperature process
(iv) Health and safety risks