Journal of Computer Networks and Communications / 2016 / Article / Tab 1

Research Article

Replica Node Detection Using Enhanced Single Hop Detection with Clonal Selection Algorithm in Mobile Wireless Sensor Networks

Table 1

Comparison of node replication attack detection techniques in Mobile Wireless Sensor Networks.

YearAuthor(s)Technique(s)Replica detection mechanismParameters used

2007Zhu et al. [9]Efficient and Distributed Detection
(EDD)
When a node exceeds the predefined threshold value, then it is detected as replicaDetection accuracy,
detection time,
storage overhead,
computation overhead, and communication overhead

2008Yu et al. [12]Extremely Efficient Detection (XED)Based on the random value exchanged between the two nodes, replicas are detectedDetection accuracy,
detection time,
storage overhead,
computation overhead, and communication overhead

2008Conti et al. [8]Simple and Co-operative Distributed Detection (SDD & CDD)Replicas are detected based on the periodic time of the nodes in the networkDetection probability,
false positive, and
false negative

2009Ho et al. [5, 7, 11]Sequential Probability Ratio Test (SPRT)Detects the replica, when the node appears at distinct locations exceeding the predefined velocityNumber of claims,
false positive, and
false negative

2012 Lou et al. [14]Single Hop DetectionWhen a node appears at different neighborhood community, replica is detectedDetection time and
communication overhead