Journal of Control Science and Engineering / 2020 / Article / Tab 5

Research Article

An Enhanced Grasshopper Optimization Algorithm to the Bin Packing Problem

Table 5

Results for multimodal functions.

FunctionTypeEGOAGOADAALOPSOOBLGOA

F8avg−7870.7306−7579.2715−7376.4956−5681.4728−6619.9581−7671.5200
std649.2707900.0826882.9292694.0512784.2524730.6476
best−9102.6546−9467.2412−9220.7846−9004.5042−8481.6966−9154.0221
worst−6794.9884−5681.3700−5402.0041−5417.6748−5343.1670−6321.3596

F9avg0.55069.71747.03459.58485.30641.1282
std1.12167.79794.13995.01573.10631.5848
best0.00000.99500.99520.99500.99506.0484E − 09
worst4.074732.833416.916419.899114.92445.9717

F10avg6.8570E083.11288.12426.01031.77120.0010
std1.8729E081.07873.94693.63250.73010.0002
best4.2697E081.64662.89302.31810.00030.0006
worst1.1399E076.207116.650914.37562.95790.0016

F11avg3.9540E130.72931.16630.06280.03670.0003
std5.6432E130.17820.16520.03020.07308.1399E − 05
best5.0071E140.28721.03660.01203.4788E − 070.0001
worst3.1125E121.02951.79570.12680.39240.0005

F12avg0.05964.771320.663711.69640.47800.0443
std0.04652.28418.11494.46390.60030.0198
best1.5136E − 020.84157.94874.82242.3850E090.0124
worst0.23229.142839.230222.32262.34530.0888

F13avg0.81747.6309103.839422.42010.19500.4521
std0.369210.0853336.041714.64350.68310.3147
best0.20730.05712.65430.01202.9372E070.0783
worst1.406140.24981865.876752.44183.67651.6232

Article of the Year Award: Outstanding research contributions of 2020, as selected by our Chief Editors. Read the winning articles.