Journal of Control Science and Engineering / 2020 / Article / Tab 6

Research Article

An Enhanced Grasshopper Optimization Algorithm to the Bin Packing Problem

Table 6

Results for fixed-dimension multimodal functions.

FunctionTypeEGOAGOADAALOPSOOBLGOA

F14avg0.99801.06412.05012.18274.07913.2005
std1.93E160.36222.02621.97463.21782.4733
best0.99800.99800.99800.99800.99800.9980
worst0.99802.982110.76327.874012.670510.7632

F15avg0.00050.00630.00230.00350.00040.0076
std0.00030.00870.00490.00670.00040.0098
best0.00030.00060.00040.00050.00030.0003
worst0.00130.02040.02040.02040.00160.0224

F16avg−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316
std4.7012E161.0871E − 122.2380E − 069.7720E − 146.6486E − 163.5117E − 06
best−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316
worst−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316−1.0316

F17avg0.39790.39790.39790.39790.39790.3979
std0.00006.0985E − 137.5449E − 073.5239E − 140.00001.0888E − 06
best0.39790.39790.39790.39790.39790.3979
worst0.39790.39790.39790.39790.39790.3979

F18avg3.000013.80003.00003.00003.90008.4000
std4.6795E1528.00541.5781E − 059.0080E − 134.92950301820.5504
best3.00003.00003.00003.00003.00003.0000
worst3.000084.00003.00013.000030.000084.0006

F19avg−3.8628−3.8091−3.8628−3.8628−3.8628−3.8357
std5.0160E − 070.1558580051.2444E − 065.5947E − 132.6962E150.1481
best−3.8628−3.8628−3.8628−3.8628−3.8628−3.8628
worst−3.8628−3.0333−3.8628−3.8628−3.8628−3.0513

F20avg−3.2341−3.2665−3.2767−3.2620−3.2665−3.2388
std0.05840.06030.06060.06110.06030.1028
best−3.3220−3.3220−3.3220−3.3220−3.3220−3.3220
worst−3.1803−3.2030−3.1831−3.2000−3.2031−3.0253

F21avg−8.2885−4.7947−6.3718−6.7001−5.0570−7.8820
std2.49262.68122.85912.99052.81392.9107
best−10.1532−10.1532−10.1532−10.1532−10.1532−10.1532
worst−5.0552−2.6305−2.6305−2.6305−2.6305−2.6304

F22avg−8.5972−7.3266−6.1121−7.4811−5.8788−7.7390
std2.84523.63923.17883.25603.55473.4005
best−10.4029−10.4029−10.4029−10.4029−10.4029−10.4029
worst−2.7659−2.7519−2.7518−2.7519−2.7519−2.7658

F23avg−9.4383−5.5672−4.7293−6.0268−5.2543−7.0597
std2.51213.68102.85523.57133.34983.8262
best−10.5364−10.5364−10.5364−10.5364−10.5364−10.5364
worst−3.1054−1.8595−2.4217−2.4217−2.4217−2.4217

Article of the Year Award: Outstanding research contributions of 2020, as selected by our Chief Editors. Read the winning articles.