Journal of Diabetes Research / 2021 / Article / Tab 1 / Review Article
Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy in Ethiopia: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Table 1 Characteristics of studies included in the systematic review and meta-analysis of the prevalence of DPN among adult patients with diabetes in Ethiopia, 2020.
Author Publication year Data collection year Study region Types of hospital Types of DM SD Sample size Number of patients with DPN by type of DM Prevalence (%) Methods for detecting DPN Quality assessment (based on NOS) Type I Type II Total Type I Type II Total Worku et al. [15 ] 2010 October 2008 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS 116 189 305 19 71 90 29.5 MNSI assessment 8 Gudina et al. [16 ] 2011 From August to November 2009 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS 117 212 329 NM NM 27 8.2 DNS instrument 7 Ejigu [17 ] 2000 September 1996 to July 1997 AA Referral Types I and II RDS 112 171 283 25 75 100 35.3 DNE instrument 9 Tsehay et al. [18 ] 2014 From May to June 2014 AA Referral Type II CS 321 73 73 22.7 DNE instrument 7 Abejew et al. [19 ] 2015 From April to May 2013 Amhara Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 216 NM NM 13 6 DNS instrument 6 Gizaw et al. [20 ] 2015 Between January 2010 and December 2013 AA Referral Types I and II RDS 122 401 523 20 89 109 20.8 DNE instrument 8 Feleke and Enquselassie [21 ] 2005 From February 2002 to July 2003 AA Mixed Types I and II CS 50 179 229 NM NM 20 10 DNE instrument 7 Wild et al. [22 ] 2000 1993 Different regions Mixed Type II CS — 1386 1386 — 146 146 10.5 MNSI assessment 8 Gebre and Assefa [23 ] 2019 From April 1 to April 2019 SNNPR General Types I and II CS 160 178 338 NM NM 50 14.8 NSS, NDS 7 Korsa et al. [24 ] 2019 Between March and April 2016 Oromia Mixed Types I and II CS 148 109 257 NM NM 8 3.11 NSS, NDS 6 Lebeta et al. [25 ] 2017 From April to May 2015 Amara Referral Type II CS — 344 344 — 344 27 7.8 NSS, NDS 9 Ahmed et al. [26 ] 2018 From July to August 2015 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS 70 90 160 NM NM 10 6.3 DNS instrument 7 Fiseha and Belete[27 ] 2018 From January 2008 to August 2015 SNNPR Referral Types I and II CO 187 495 682 NM NM 116 17 DNS instrument 8 Jember et al. [9 ] 2017 From February 2016 to June 30 2016 Amara Referral Types I and II CS 164 204 368 84 108 192 52.2 DNS instrument 8 Tilahun et al. [28 ] 2017 October to December of 2015 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS 98 138 236 NM NM 60 25.4 NSS, NDS 7 Tesfaye [29 ] 2014 From October to November 2013 AA Referral Types I and II CS 56 191 247 NM NM 25 10.1 Clinical examination 6 Jarso et al. [30 ] 2011 December 2009 to February 2010 AA Referral Types I and II CS 104 280 384 86 99 185 48.2 DNS instrument 9 Lester [31 ] 1984 1982 AA Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 849 NM NM 235 27.8 DNS instrument 8 Fiseha and Belete [27 ] 2011 2010 AA Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 724 NM NM 90 12.4 Clinical examination 9 Gill et al. [32 ] 2008 2007 AA Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 108 NM NM 43 41 Clinical examination 7 Fasil et al. [33 ] 2019 February–March 2017 Amara Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 367 NM NM 29 7.9 DNS assessment 8 Lester [34 ] 1983 1983 AA Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 809 NM NM 47 5.8 DNE instrument 7 Lester et al. [35 ] 1976 1976 AA Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 404 NM NM 38 9.4 DNS assessment 6 Teshager [36 ] 2016 March–April 2016 Amhara Referral Types I and II CS 178 238 416 NM NM 14 3.4 DNS assessment 9 Kefeany [37 ] 2017 March–May 2017 AA Referral Type II CS — 121 121 — 49 49 40.5 NSS, NDS 8 Kassahun et al. [38 ] 2016 February–April 2014 Oromia Referral Type II CS — 309 309 — 146 146 47.2 DNE instrument 8 Eticha et al. [39 ] 2016 February 2015 Tigray Referral Type II CS — 384 384 — 125 125 32.6 NSS, NDS 7 Cheneke et al. [40 ] 2016 From May to July 2012 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 148 NM NM 18 12.2 Clinical examination 6 Shiels et al. [8 ] 2018 From October 2016 to January 2017 AA Referral (police) Type II CS — 414 414 — 8 8 1.9 NSS, NDS 8 Mariam et al. [41 ] 2017 From March to April 2016 Amhara Referral Types I and II CS 110 169 279 NM NM 28 10 NSS, NDS 7 Demoz et al. [42 ] 2019 From August 2017 to July 2018 AA Referral Type II CS — 357 357 — 167 167 46.8 Clinical examination 7 Yigazu and Deese [43 ] 2017 From February to March 2016 Oromia General Type II CS — 174 174 — 31 31 17.8 Clinical examination 8 Woldu et al. [44 ] 2018 March 2017 Amhara Referral Type II CS — 341 341 — 64 64 18.8 DNE instrument 9 Abdissa et al. [45 ] 2019 June to August 2019 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS 48 229 277 NM NM 129 46.6 NSS, NDS 9 Tamura et al. [46 ] 2020 March 1 to April 28, 2019 AA Referral Type II CS — 346 346 — 53 53 15.3 MNSI assessment 7 Abdissa et al. [47 ] 2020 September to November 2019 Oromia Referral Type II CS — 336 336 — 196 196 53.6 DNS instrument 8 Woldemariam et al. [48 ] 2020 March to May 2019 AA Referral Types I and II CS NM NM 161 NM NM 44 27.3 DNE instrument 9 YimamAhmed et al. [49 ] 2020 February to March 2019 Oromia Referral Types I and II CS 24 76 100 NM NM 45 45 DNE instrument 9
AA: Addis Ababa; SNNPR: South Nation Nationalities and People Representative; NM: not mentioned; CS: cross-sectional; SD: study design; RDS: retrospective descriptive study; CO: cohort; NOS: Newcastle-Ottawa Scale; NSS: neuropathy symptom. The score: DNS: diabetic neuropathy symptom; DNE: diabetic neuropathy examination; MNSI: Michigan Neuropathy Screening Instrument.